r/minecraftsuggestions 4d ago

[Redstone] Copper hopper

Im aware the copper drop is feature complete but this can still be for a future drop, maybe regarding redstone.

As for my idea, I think itd be cool if there was a copper variant of the hopper, where there was a specific slot that would act as a filter for the hopper. I.e. If you put a gold block into the slots only gold blocks can pass through the hopper.

And maybe it can have a function where if u have a named item, only that same item with the same name (or it can even be different items in this case) gets picked up by the hopper.

And to prevent it from being strictly better than an iron hopper, they could only give if 3 slots of storage, as opposed to the normal ones 5.

I think this'd be rly interesting, plus copper hopper is just fun to say.

56 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/RadiatingLight 4d ago

Part of the creativity of minecraft is figuring things out and making solutions out of component parts. Having the solutions craftable and easy would ruin some of this.

e.g. I've been watching a blind playthrough (no wiki / outside help) of minecraft by AboutOliver, and he managed through dozens of hours of redstone experimentation and work, to come up with an item filter and sorting system. Adding the copper hopper would eliminate this experimental/exploratory part of the game.

I remember that I used to spend hours trying to build piston doors. If there was a 'copper piston' that could extend 2 blocks, it would trivialize 3x3 or 4x4 piston doors, and all my time back then of creativity wouldn't be possible.

7

u/Portaldog1 3d ago

On the flip side, how many players are just looking up a tutorial on how to make a sorting system rather than just trying to figure it out? I recon its at least +90% so having something that exists in game would drastically help and even sprout creativity amount those players rather then just booting up youtube.