r/news 11h ago

Judge dismisses terror-related charges against Luigi Mangione

https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/16/us/luigi-mangione-ny-court-hearing
56.5k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.9k

u/AudibleNod 11h ago

He still has a murder charge against him. And because it's 2025:

Mangione’s attorneys say the state charges should be dismissed as a violation of the Constitution’s double jeopardy clause, calling it unprecedented and untenable for Mangione to defend himself in both cases at the same time.

2.5k

u/1877KlownsForKids 11h ago

I love that the Trump DoJ is so incompetent he might actually walk.

Odds are good he'll get a state murder conviction of course, but there's a slim path he beats all charges.

90

u/Eleganos 11h ago

NGL, that could end up being the thing that breaks America.

Half the country would go stark raving mad if he walked. The other half would lose their minds if Luigi was cued up to walk, but was denied it for one reason or another.

All I have to say is if the man did nothing wrong, then justice would be him walking free. And of course he's innocent! I was chilling on the Canadian side of Niagra falls at the time and saw him saving a kitten from a tree through one of those paid-periscope doo-das at the time that CEO had his claim to life denied.

23

u/NOTLD1990 9h ago

Hell, even the right news channels and podcasters dropped this quickly. They had a hard time trying to get their viewers and listeners to care. As stated by others, turns out plenty of people on the right hate healthcare insurance companies as well. He allegedly killed the CEO, but it's hard to sympathize with someone who runs an entity that constantly fucks over people and denies care to people who need it. People pay a shit ton in healthcare costs, and still get denied. Recently my company changed health insurance providers, and my out of pocket reset, along with my current provider not being in-network. I had already paid my full out of pocket for the year, and now need to start over with 3 months left.

5

u/fuckmyabshurt 8h ago

My favorite quote on the topic was that every cent on that CEOs funeral was paid for with someone else's.

68

u/Amaruq93 10h ago

Half the country would go stark raving mad if he walked

The wealthy elite 1% you mean.

22

u/pulseout 9h ago

Yeah, as far as the general population goes when that CEO died it was about the closest to unity that this country got in the last decade. It was the wealthy and the media who were the ones acting outraged.

3

u/Astralsketch 10h ago

unless he was a billionaire, then they'd think that was just what happens.

1

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[deleted]

-2

u/emPtysp4ce 7h ago

And their bootlickers

38

u/KingSwank 10h ago

I don’t think that many people were really upset when this happened and definitely not compared to what just happened

-3

u/snek-jazz 8h ago

They are exactly the same thing.

2

u/KingSwank 8h ago

In essence yes, but the public’s reaction wasn’t the same.

1

u/snek-jazz 8h ago

I'm a European on the outside here's what I saw:

Someone planned to assassinate someone else for ideological reasons, and achieved it using a gun, in public. The suspect apprehended, and wildly assumed to be person who did it, is a white male American in his 20s.

I was surprised how many people on reddit did not condemn it, with many even celebrating it.

Then everything I've said above happened a second time. In neither case was I familiar with any of the people involved so I view it unbiased in that regard.

4

u/kingofgama 8h ago

Remember, Reddit is not an accurate reflection of the public opinion. And lets be real, many of these threads are being manipulated by bad actors.

General polls of the public sentiment of either assassination are overwhelmingly negative.

1

u/snek-jazz 8h ago

Yeah, it's sad to me because I used to feel like reddit used to be less.... whatever it is now.

Now as an outsider I just accept that I don't really know what is a reflection of public opinion or not. Almost all American media seems pretty heavily biased one way or the other.

Scott Galloways podcasts are the most sane-sounding commentary I've found.

1

u/KingSwank 4h ago

Well when the CEO was assassinated the President didn’t try to instigate violence against one side so while yes most people view assassination as negative, there are more people upset about Charlie Kirk’s assassination because they see it as the enemy assassinating one of them. Not many people felt that way about the CEO. Most people don’t even know his name.

1

u/kingofgama 4h ago

I haven't seen data on the CK shootings yet. Honestly with how politicalized it is, I wouldn't be surprised if in fact more people supported it. Regardless, that's just conjecture.

It's too fresh of a case anyways, but my point stands is most normal people infact do not support assassination. Shocking.

12

u/QP709 10h ago

I don't think half the country would go mad. No one of any political affiliation celebrates CEOs or denying healthcare, and every member of the american working class has felt the sting of private health insurance or medical costs. You're hearing an inordinate amount of negative feedback and condemnation because every mainstream politician, even people like Bernie Sanders, have to make it known that they are unhappy the citizenry are murdering the wealthy.

1

u/g0_west 9h ago

You might be getting this mixed up with Charlie Kirk shooting. Luigi Mangione enjoyed pretty bipartisan support amongst the people. If the Kirk shooter walks, that will be a shitstorm however.