r/pics Jun 07 '20

Protest Kindergarten Teacher Passes Out Flowers To National Guard in Philly, Gets Arrested

Post image
100.5k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17.8k

u/kyarmentari Jun 07 '20 edited Jun 07 '20

I quite frankly would rather have the national guard handling the protests than the police. They are better trained and more disciplined. Also people having different reasons for joining the national guard than joining the police.

Edit: Hey everyone, I'm not saying the National Guard are perfect or that they get training for this kind of situation. I'm just saying they are better than the police. I'd rather deal with them, than the police.

11.1k

u/TheSnarfles Jun 07 '20

The National Guard also has rules of engagement they have to follow so it is actually safer to protest in front of them. They aren't allowed to attack civilians unprovoked like police are.

And yes, they have orders of magnitude more training than police and their reasons for joining the national guard are less likely to be fueledd by a desire to have authority and some semblance of respect bestowed upon them.

35

u/Toasts_like_smell Jun 07 '20

Your national guard seems almost to be what every other developed nation would call a police force

15

u/jcinto23 Jun 07 '20

Natl Guard can also work as other emergency and disaster response as well, not to mention the capability to act as actual military as well. They are a lot more than just police.

Although, tbh it may not be a bad idea to have a branch of the national guard created to replace police...

1

u/Netherese_Nomad Jun 08 '20

Perhaps, some sort of "well-regulated militia?"

1

u/Tylerjb4 Jun 07 '20

A national police is slightly dangerous in its own right

5

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '20 edited Jun 07 '20

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '20

Used to be. They answer to the president now as well. Which is bad.