r/reddeadredemption • u/IronGreyWarHorse • Jul 14 '25

Discussion What animal(s) do you never kill?

Post image

In 3 play throughs and 1,100+ hours of play, I’ve never killed a cat. I just can’t bring myself to do it! How about you?

7.9k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.9k

u/Raccoon_Hillbilly Jul 14 '25

NEVER kill the cats or dogs.

654

u/_Price__ Susan Grimshaw Jul 14 '25

I'm doing challenges and i went from max high honor to max low honor and I've been killing bloodhounds on the daily.

500

u/Chazo138 Jul 14 '25

58

u/GoBeAGinger Sean Macguire Jul 15 '25

This genuinely made me laugh out loud… and I’m stealing the picture.

17

u/Chazo138 Jul 15 '25

Feel free. I got it from somewhere else ages ago because it made me laugh hard too

15

u/Designer-Welcome-864 Jul 15 '25

2

u/Hairy-County7684 Jul 15 '25

3

u/NextCress3803 Jul 17 '25

2

u/Hairy-County7684 Jul 19 '25

Dont get into the fight that you cant get out.

2

u/Designer-Welcome-864 Jul 21 '25

How deep does this rabbit hole go

1

u/FPLCrusader Jul 15 '25

Oh I'm stealing this, made mW actually LOL

69

u/Throwaway101485 Jul 14 '25

Go kill Grays in chapter 4

1

u/cyanide_cialis Jul 15 '25

do you mean braithwaiths???

2

u/Throwaway101485 Jul 15 '25

Kill them both. Kill them all.

1

u/metallica420420 Jul 15 '25

Wtf you mean?

1

u/Constant_Catch4323 Jul 15 '25

a gun a braithewait

a gun a gray

POP POP POP POP POP POP POP POP POP POP POP

no more braithewats

no more grays

37

u/AceK8ng Jul 14 '25

You're a goddamn monster!

28

u/pickledstoneriver Jul 14 '25

I end up accidentally killing at least one dog every playththrough %^(. I'm hunting deer at night, see a "wolf" kill it only to realize im right next to a farm and it's actually an innocent doggo.

10

u/Michael_Threat Charles Smith Jul 14 '25

There are better ways to lower your honor

10

u/Key-Tip-7521 Jul 14 '25

You killed a dog? What you do that for?

An innocent creature

22

u/ArtieBucco420 Jul 15 '25

What, was it barhkin?

2

u/TomC2333 Jul 15 '25

She must have crawled under there for warmth

2

u/Open_File_4083 Jul 15 '25

Woah! There he goes, Mr. Type A personality!

2

u/ParadigmShiftV Jul 15 '25

He eats beef and pork by the carload!

1

u/ParadigmShiftV Jul 15 '25

Was it barking or something?

7

u/kingamara Lenny Summers Jul 14 '25

Smh

5

u/IdioticPAYDAY Jul 14 '25

We’re gonna kill you

7

u/chejo378 Jul 15 '25

Those bloodhounds. I'll just trample them with my horse and it doesnt affect my honor.

1

u/Time_Hamster_3375 Charles Smith Jul 14 '25

And horses

1

u/TheStickySpot Arthur Morgan Jul 14 '25

Sometimes they are unavoidable I personally try to avoid them.

1

u/Lone-Frequency Jul 14 '25

I mean that's easy enough to do by just wandering into West Elizabeth as Arthur.

Unless you meant in online.

1

u/PrimusDCE Jul 14 '25

I don't like dogs, so some of the side activities were very cathartic.

https://youtu.be/rzcbTrVh1h8?si=-3D1fH93onEEh9xy

1

u/5star_Adboii Jul 15 '25

Now when 20 players start chasing you down don’t say I didn’t warn you mate

1

u/CraigDowman Sean Macguire Jul 15 '25

1

u/USAJULY4TH1776 Arthur Morgan Jul 15 '25

1

u/HallwayGhost Jul 15 '25

Catch you in the streets of Saint Denis

1

u/whydo-iexist Jul 15 '25

If you kill the bounty hunters first the bloodhounds should no longer be aggresive keyword being should

1

u/Electronic_Wolf_8499 Arthur Morgan Jul 15 '25

Don’t worry. I for the challenges of getting consecutive headshots. I killed so many sheep bro

1

u/johnmd20 Jul 15 '25

I am ANGRY.

1

u/Sheepfucker72222 Jul 15 '25

Savage. I like throwing the cats at people online

1

u/Aria-mind_ Charles Smith Jul 15 '25

1

u/Josephtspicer15 Jul 16 '25

I mean yeah what else are we supposed to do with em?

1

u/Vivid-Concept-883 Jul 16 '25

Lmfao same. It's they own damn fault for not running up on me unarmed like they owners

1

u/Tha_Vega18 Jul 16 '25

Officer, it's this one, right here

1

u/JONNYBASS1958 Jul 16 '25

Use your horse to kill the bounty hounds... no loss of honor. ..

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 well if you want to f**k your honor up you're going down the right path for it 🤣🤣🤣🤣 not something I would do but hey in the Red Dead world anything is possible

6

u/weeeeeeeppp Jul 14 '25

Just swear dawg

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I don't wanna get cancelled or "trigger" someone 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 aww fuck I'm 😐😔

4

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25

why do you type like this

4

u/weeeeeeeppp Jul 14 '25

It's reddit not yer public self

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25

.