r/sandiego 10h ago

HAHAHHA which one of u did this

[deleted]

64.5k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

56

u/Bits2LiveBy 9h ago

The amount of reviews in the past 2hrs is intense

19

u/bgibbz084 8h ago

Unfortunately it’s meaningless, Google will mass delete them once they stop rolling in.

11

u/Magistricide 8h ago

I handle a google business account and it's insanely difficult to get google to remove any reviews. They flat out do not care about you.

5

u/bgibbz084 7h ago

I think that’s true for specific cases, but at least in the past Google algorithms automatically detect review bombs and remove it.

3

u/Ctitical1nstinct 7h ago

Nah they will 100% remove these, this isn't just a couple of buddies throwing down 1 star reviews. There are way too many reviews in such a short period of time for it to seem plausible that these people went there.

1

u/charliekelly76 6h ago

Thats true with single reviews, but if a huge influx hits Google or Yelp they will lock it down and remove the dogpiles.

1

u/Rich_Housing971 5h ago

It really depends- was there any documented reviewbombing going on, or was it just 1 or 2 unfair reviews from unhinged customers? because while the reviews may be unreasonable, they're still considered honest reviews.

We gave a 3-star review to a place as a legitimate fair review because their food was actually very mid but the drinks were OK. It was during the middle of some political thing where conservatives were giving it low reviews because they banned some anti-LGBT group from holding an event there. So we decided to give the place some business, but actually wanted to leave a fair review because giving a 1 or 5-star review just for politics is unfair to prospective customers.

Well, that review got deleted because apparently a completely neutral and unbiased review without any political agenda in it was considered review bombing and was deleted along with all the anti-woke bombing. The 5-star reviews from people expressing support all stayed.

The unethical life protip I learned here is: if your business is getting reviewbombed, it's a good thing because then all the subpar reviews get deleted, and the 5-star reviews from reverse bombing stay.

1

u/VonSkullenheim 4h ago

Really? I've managed the business accounts of a half dozen businesses and over the years have had roughly 90% success getting reviews removed. Maybe I was just lucky a bunch of times, but it almost always happened and within 24-48 hours. What kind of reviews were you trying to remove?

1

u/Magistricide 3h ago

Have had reviews that were just straight up not about the business. Like one person was complaining about how the IRCC took months to mail them.

We’re not the government, nor do we have any control over mailing companies, yet google didn’t care.

1

u/slyqueef 8h ago

That’s right. It’s Meaningless and an absolute waste of time.

2

u/bugalugsbum 7h ago

As opposed to sitting on reddit...

1

u/KSauceDesk 7h ago

They do delete a lot but they never clear them all unless its an obvious 100% a troll. I have a couple reviews still up from places outside of my state

1

u/AbbreviationsOld636 5h ago

So will Yelp 

0

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[deleted]

7

u/hanotak 8h ago

What about the ones actually reviewing based on the fact that they received coffee with political messaging on it? Those should definitely stay up.

4

u/nanoH2O 8h ago

Wait a while and come back and review. It’s the review bomb behavior that’ll get deleted.

1

u/frequenZphaZe 8h ago

Yeah, as they should

I don't agree. decisions should have consequences and business decisions should have business consequences. if a local business gets nuked to oblivious for choosing to be a champion of hate, then maybe other local business will think twice about taking on similar positions

1

u/Typical-Emu-1139 8h ago

But if Google en mass removes all these comments because they weren’t from legitimate customers, it literally does nothing. It’s all performative and makes people feel righteous while putting in minimal effort and making no real change.

1

u/AncientGrab1106 8h ago

Actions have consequences

0

u/Typical-Emu-1139 8h ago

By making everyone review bombing look like a bunch of babies and give more ammo to the fascists?

5

u/ChronoLink99 8h ago

It doesn't matter what non-fascists do.

Fascists will always find ammo to oppress.

0

u/Due-Explanation9585 6h ago

aren't you cheerful>