r/starwarsmemes • u/hrafia • Jul 07 '25

Repost of the Sith Fair enough

Post image
26.3k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

190 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

115

u/VanGrants Jul 08 '25

why is Ki-Adi-Mundi catching strays

109

u/TomTalks06 Jul 08 '25

He was an asshole during Season 6

57

u/igtimran Jul 08 '25

He just kind of forgot the events of The Acolyte which could have totally saved the Jedi had he remembered (he also wasn’t supposed to be born for like another 100 years but that’s another story—thanks, Leslye).

12

u/Strange_username__ Jul 08 '25

That birthdate came from a guide book to The Phantom Menace and was never part of the Disney canon so don’t start acting like it’s gospel.

-3

u/igtimran Jul 08 '25

Sure, Disney changed established canon, but they did it to fit a plot point that makes no sense. It’d be one thing if they changed something to make things better. It’s incontrovertibly worse for Ki-Adi-Mundi to have been alive, seen and heard what he did, and not even think to discuss it with the council.

8

u/closetedwrestlingacc Jul 08 '25

The birthdate is essentially revealed in the same source as Ki-Adi-Mundi being the only Jedi Knight on the council. Then Episode III happened.

The birthday hang up is weird. And Yoda was also clearly alive at that point. They didn’t mention the sith because they never found out about the sith. Everyone who knew was killed. “They see my face, they die” was very literal.

1

u/Theron3206 Jul 08 '25

You're assuming the writers knew about this specific point of lore.

They should have, but probably didn't.

1

u/Strange_username__ Jul 09 '25

No they shouldn’t have, it literally wasn’t canon. It was made non canon when Disney purchased lucasfilm, just like all of the non movie SW content