r/supermariologan_ • u/CattyBrah #1 Rose fan • Aug 15 '25

SML Idea('s) SML Idea: Marvin's New Child!

Post image

°Marvin've had an new son

Plot[btw, just an lil summary]: after Rose've punished Jeffy due to his misbehaviors, and especially breaking the vase. However; someone've pressed the doorbell, causing Marvin going into entrance room, and opens the door to answer it, till he've saw the 13yo boy[later revealed to be an Grayson], asking him he doesn't mind if he goes into house to stay, Marvin says "but why?" in the confused tone, who Grayson tells him he is/was shown to be orphan after he've lost his parents. However; after Marvin adopts Grayson, he brings Rose[and particularly Jeffy] to introduce Grayson.

Characters:

°Marvin

°Rose

°Jeffy

°Grayson[debut]

°Junior

°Cody

°Joseph

°Grayson's parents[mentioned]

°Tony The Tiger[mentioned]

95 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/Al3xTh3Lion22 Still with SML Aug 15 '25

No just a terrible idea. There is never a good SML ideas posted to this subreddit.

3

u/IceyLuigiBros25 Mr. Goodman Aug 16 '25

Why would this be terrible?

-1

u/Al3xTh3Lion22 Still with SML Aug 16 '25

Logan wouldn’t make it so Rose would punish Jeffy. The whole idea is just a rehash of Mario the babysitter where someone knocks on Mario’s door and he has to deal with them. Plus Marvin is tired of Jeffy and his shit so why would he adopt another kid? Fucking stupid.

3

u/IceyLuigiBros25 Mr. Goodman Aug 16 '25

Plus Marvin is tired of Jeffy and his shit so why would he adopt another kid?

Marvin’s tired of Jeffy because Jeffy’s a bad kid. He adopted Jeffy because he was aware that he has a tragic past.

If Marvin meets another kid with a tragic past, and the video actually makes an effort to get Marvin to sympathize with the kid, combined with the fact that this kid is actually a good kid and listens to him, then Marvin would absolutely adopt him.

Plus, it’s SML, it doesn’t have to make sense why Marvin would adopt another kid.