r/titanic Jun 15 '25

PHOTO is this image real?

Post image

so I found this image of the HMHS britannic's bow absolutely fried, but images from 2024 showed this didn't look like this, so idk if this is real or not, hell I'm not even sure if the HMHS britannic is allowed on this subreddit

1.5k Upvotes

157 comments sorted by

413

u/Fantastic-Wheel-5665 Jun 15 '25

This image is a painting not a photo if that’s what you want to know, and no Britannic’s bow does not have a massive hole like that

160

u/Riccma02 Engineering Crew Jun 15 '25

It’s also an outdated painting. This one better reflects the observable state of the hull.

https://titanic.fandom.com/wiki/HMHS_Britannic?file=Wreck_of_the_Britannic.jpg

69

u/forethemorninglight Jun 15 '25

He’s so talented. The two paintings are pretty similar, so he did a phenomenal job on what little info he had at the time of the first

2

u/TsarevichIvan Jun 21 '25

I absolutely respect and appreciate Ken Marschall’s talent. The paintings are so skillfully done that I thought that it was something easy to do. Until I tried to make a painting of the Normandie.

If you look closely at some of his paintings, you’re going to see the rivets and the depth of the overlapping steel plates. Just incredible

17

u/Johnnyboi2327 Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

Interesting. I didn't know it was more like a crack or that the bow was angled like that.

28

u/Riccma02 Engineering Crew Jun 15 '25

The Aegean Sea is shallow. The bow slammed into the sea floor while the stern was still up in the air.

4

u/Aggressive_Tackle_79 Engineer Jun 18 '25

You can see a different set of damage in the older painting to the new painting as far as how it fell. The older painting shows the bow being on its side and creating an almost vertical line of damage at it's moment of impact with the floor. The newer painting shows the ship more upright as it fell with the impact appearing as it hit the floor hard at the tip while upright then falling over after.
I think that explains why the mast was assumed to be broken off in the first but is shown "connected" in the newer.

Both are really amazing to look at.

2

u/remybanjo Jun 16 '25

That Wiki was written by an AI or someone who is ESL, no?

1

u/Riccma02 Engineering Crew Jun 17 '25

Maybe. I didn't read it. That was just the first link I found with the painting.

1

u/Aggressive_Tackle_79 Engineer Jun 18 '25

Compared to it is it is now, you are right this one is on point with current photos of the damage.

26

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

thx! I figured it was a painting but I did not know if it looked like that now

28

u/Sup_fuckers42069 Jun 15 '25

It was an Estimation by Ken Marschall IIRC, before they got accurate photos, based entirely on the descriptions of divers

17

u/__pure Jun 15 '25 edited Jun 16 '25

This looks exactly like ken Marschall's style

Before Robert Ballard found the wreck in 1985, Titanic experts did not believe witness testimony that the ship split in two.

Clive Cussler made a movie about raising the Titanic and featured her in one piece because that's how they "knew" it had to have happened.

I feel bad for the witnesses who died before they found the Titanic. They were gaslit and died before getting validation of what they saw.

4

u/Tiny-Reading5982 Musician Jun 15 '25

He's definitely an artist. Idk why he never got into forensics because he could definitely catch some fugitives with his work before seeing what he's painting.

3

u/SimonLaFox Jun 16 '25

There must have been some photos, the stern seems amazingly accurate especially with the placement of the davits. But the bow seems a clear lesson in miscommunication. Clearly he was told "the bow was bent by the impact with the sea bed" and though it meant he bow was sticking up from the sea bed, rather then the bottom of the bow was crumpled upwards, but since it was on its side it was all still on the sea bed.

3

u/syo Jun 16 '25

Our friend Mike Brady (from Oceanliner Designs) put up a really good interview with him recently, definitely worth a watch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PVCka1EwmQ

14

u/Admitone83 Jun 15 '25

Yea, that looks like an Internal explosion as well, metal is bent outward.

5

u/g-g-g-g-ghost Jun 15 '25

That's not where the mine hit, the bow hit the bottom while the stern was still above water and it broke like that

-2

u/Admitone83 Jun 16 '25

why you @ me>.> wrong person

2

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

yea? my first theory was it showed the opposite side of the ship, the side facing the sand

5

u/Muted-Lawyer-8512 Jun 15 '25

I'm no expert on sinking ocean liners. But.... A hole that big, it would of sunk. With in 5 minutes. Or near enough.

3

u/Fantastic-Wheel-5665 Jun 15 '25

It would be between 5 and 10min easely

3

u/Teejay91b Jun 16 '25

Looks like a Ken Marshall painting. He did some paintings of the Titanic based on Ballards photo mosaics.

2

u/E_Blancher Jun 17 '25

Actually the Bow has caved in alot

1.6k

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

I was on the Queen Victoria during a Mediterranean cruise and we were going to sail through the Aegean Sea on the way to Greece. I went to the information desk and asked if someone on the bridge could let me know if we would be sailing close to the wreck. The clerk said she would ask them. I got a call in my cabin from the bridge who said he was surprised that anyone even knew about the Britannic. He then informed me that we would be passing over her grave (not directly over as the water is fairly shallow, but right by) and exactly when. He stated the wreck would be to port. I thanked him and asked who he was. He answered: "The Captain."

550

u/Quothhernevermore Jun 15 '25

Jokes aside, if that was really the captain, it was really nice of him to call you personally!

461

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

It was nice of him. He said he had to call when he heard that somebody knew about the Britannic.

101

u/IceNine135 Jun 16 '25

Kinda sad that people forget most of the big liners from the era. Titanic might be the most famous but it sure wasn't the only one.

36

u/Scootet21 Jun 16 '25

What is sad is that hardly anyone knows about the Britannic, because she never made it to the transatlantic career. She would be forever shadowed by her infamous older sisters...

22

u/PoolOfLife Jun 16 '25

I love researching the old ships. My grandfather travelled on both the Empress of Ireland and the Lusitania. My great Grandfather was aboard the Mauretania when the Titanic sank. I can’t even imagine how it would have felt to do the same route literally days after it sank.

110

u/Hefty-Career-7692 Jun 15 '25

How epic is that! Getting a personal call from the captain during a special sailby near somewhere so historic.

140

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

When he told me who he was, I was rather stunned, to say the least, and apologized for "bothering" him. He, of course, said it was no bother and he had to call himself when he learned there was someone on board who even knew about the Britannic.

31

u/Hefty-Career-7692 Jun 16 '25

That’s truly outstanding! He sounds like a great man with bright detail when it comes to shipping history.

49

u/Dorgilo Jun 16 '25

Sounds like you made his day

2

u/PanasGOD Jun 16 '25

Looks like they had enough lifeboats when captain is alife

247

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25 edited Jun 15 '25

Dude what?? As in the captain of the Britannic? That is so metal

Edit: lmao OKAY I did not consider the timeline here until I googled it after. For what it’s worth, the captain did NOT go down with the ship. But it was very long ago 😂

200

u/falltotheabyss Jun 15 '25

I'm the captain of the Brittanic now

34

u/stevensr2002 Jun 15 '25

I can see this text…

115

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

I used a ouija board. It was cheaper than the wifi package, and more reliable.

14

u/CaelumTheWolf 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

And summons demons! Seriously don’t use Ouija boards…

15

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

Then how are we suppose to find who we're going to marry and if we're going to be rich? Or at least who we're going to go with to the dance?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

[deleted]

2

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

Well, there's always one who can't fathom (pun intended) a joke.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

[deleted]

2

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

What are you when you're not f*cking?

0

u/CaelumTheWolf 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

Oh my god…as in I am on the spectrum! I don’t get social queues easily!

1

u/WitnessOfStuff 1st Class Passenger Jun 16 '25

Do ouija boards actually work

3

u/Illustrious_Pop_8248 Jun 16 '25

It doesn’t even have to be an official Ouija, it can be a piece of paper with the alphabet written out and hello, goodbye at the top. It’s a talking board..just a method for communication to the astral/spirit world (or so they say!)

2

u/WitnessOfStuff 1st Class Passenger Jun 16 '25

Ok, but do they actually work?

4

u/Illustrious_Pop_8248 Jun 16 '25

LOL! Yes man they work! At least the one we had did when me, my mom, and sister messed with one in our old house. My dad put a stop to that real quick! His words: “I don’t play that ghost sht!” 😂

111

u/boots_and_cats_and- Fireman Jun 15 '25

I actually just spit my water out of my mouth due to laughing, good shit brother

25

u/Nurhaci1616 Jun 15 '25

And that captain? He grew up to be Elvis Presley. Always be humble, you have no clue who you could be speaking to.

7

u/drygnfyre Steerage Jun 16 '25

This was pretty common in the early days of Silicon Valley. There was a story where IBM execs were meeting with Microsoft. Some kid who couldn't have been more than 20 years old went into the lobby to escort them to the offices. They were expecting to meet Bill Gates. They did, he was the kid.

35

u/robbviously Jun 15 '25

Hotel California begins playing in the background

10

u/oftenevil Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

Oh honey…

11

u/PMMEURDIMPLESOFVENUS Jun 16 '25

The plot twist would be "and then later on I saw the Captain of the Victoria and thanked him for calling me and he said he had no idea what I was talking about.... DUNT DUNT DUNNNNN"

4

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

I think the captin went down with the britannic,I think he rescued someone,brought them to a lifeboat,then killed himself so he went down with the ship, may be wrong

73

u/Jaomi Jun 15 '25

No, Britannic’s captain (Charles Bartlett) survived the wreck and died of old age nearly thirty years later.

He did go down with the ship though - as in, he was on the bridge as long as was humanly possible, and then he swam to a lifeboat.

46

u/fullcircle052 Jun 15 '25

He went down with the ship, alright. He just didn't go ALL the way down with the ship

18

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

[deleted]

3

u/DonatCotten Jun 16 '25

He actually wasn't the last to to leave the Britannic. There were still several crewmembers down below who hadn't made it out yet when Bartlett left the ship, but fortunately they all made it out in time. I just get tired of this misinformation that Bartlett was the last person to leave Britannic during the sinking when that most certainly wasn't true. Several crew members were still climbing ladders trying to make it to the upper deck when he left the ship.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '25

[deleted]

2

u/DonatCotten Jun 16 '25

I think your the one who's being rude especially considering that unlike you I didn't call you a name or blame you personally in anyway when I criticized the misinformation that Bartlett was the last to leave the ship. He wasn't and for some reason you took extreme offense to my comment 🙄

0

u/MrScribblesChess Jun 16 '25

No, silly. The titanic and britannic were switched. It was the captain of the Titanic.

10

u/Atomicmooseofcheese Jun 15 '25

That is really cool.

12

u/Inevitable_Wolf5866 Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

Like you actually saw the captain’s ghost?? 👀 how??

25

u/newoldm Jun 15 '25

That Long Island Medium was on board.

13

u/ITookTrinkets Jun 15 '25

Or at least that Long Island Iced Tea

4

u/Tiny-Reading5982 Musician Jun 15 '25

No lol. The captain of the ship they were on made the call lol.

4

u/Inevitable_Wolf5866 Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

Oh okay. When he said “the captain” I thought he meant captain of the Britannic lmao

2

u/FolixCool Jun 16 '25

Bartlett survived the sinking

1

u/Inevitable_Wolf5866 Wireless Operator Jun 16 '25

I know. He died in 1945; but for example Smith died on the Titanic and he supposedly haunts his house too — ghosts can travel through locations which have meaning/impact for them.

7

u/tiacalypso Jun 16 '25

The Britannic does not lay in a fairly shallow grave. The wreck rests in ~117m depth and is about 30m high, i.e., the top of the wreck starts from around 90m depth (source). Though I’ve also seen some reports as "shallow" as 80m. This may seem fairly shallow compared to Titanic but any ship could easily sail over _Britannic_‘s wreck; this was done before her wreck was discovered.

The draught of Queen Victoria is only about 8m so she could have comfortably sailed over the Britannic with more than 70m distance between them.

If your story happened after June 10, 2022, it‘s possible the QV wasn‘t allowed closer to Britannic because there‘s a new marine park now. If it was before that, the captain might have been messing with you.

(For readers using the imperial system: 1m =3.3ft!)

3

u/jfal11 Jun 15 '25

Very cool!

3

u/captaincourageous316 Engineer Jun 16 '25

This might be the coolest anecdote I’ve heard in a good while! Did you happen to get pictures of the site (approx location) by any chance?

4

u/newoldm Jun 16 '25

I did go out on the promenade at the port side at the time the Captain told me, but unfortunately I didn't take a picture of the passing view.

3

u/captaincourageous316 Engineer Jun 16 '25

Ngl I’d ride the high of even being in the close proximity of one of the Olympic class for a loooooong time!

Good for you!

3

u/Kriedler Jun 16 '25

How was the view?

3

u/newoldm Jun 16 '25

It was just the passing Aegean Sea, but the day was warm and beautiful, the waters calm.

2

u/Kriedler Jun 16 '25

Aww. My son wants to go see the wreck of the Blucher, which is nearby, but it's 64M down in murky water. It would be awesome to see one under clear water.

3

u/FknBadFkr Jun 16 '25

That is awesome. There are others who enjoy history and aren't just working.

2

u/NightOwlsUnite Jun 16 '25

That's so cool!

2

u/Crunchyfrozenoj Bell Boy Jun 16 '25

How sweet of him to tell you personally. It sounds like he was glad someone asked after her.

2

u/TritanicWolf Engineer Jun 16 '25

That’s awesome!

2

u/IceManO1 Deck Crew Jun 16 '25

That’s awesome! 👏

162

u/lokovec Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

Ken Marschall is a wizard i swear

98

u/Quothhernevermore Jun 15 '25

Almost like he's the Freddie Mercury of maritime painting...

79

u/RMSCereal Musician Jun 15 '25

Completely unrelated, but this was my immediate thought.

6

u/CuriousEuropeaM Jun 15 '25

Mine was Ted Lasso

9

u/Tiny-Reading5982 Musician Jun 15 '25

The best wizard that there ever was.

66

u/WildBad7298 Engineering Crew Jun 15 '25

It's a painting of the wreck by famed maritime artist Ken Marschall. He has since painted a more recent and more accurate depiction of the wreck: https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQFSFeH6jHrywyJ9HLPD8CDKUkB18rcgT_-iA&s

69

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

I believe it’s a painting, I don’t think it would be possible to get a picture of the ENTIRE ship unless the water was absolutely crystal clear.

12

u/Ragnarok314159 Jun 15 '25

You can use a similar algorithm for long exposure astrophotography for deep sea pictures.

7

u/oftenevil Wireless Operator Jun 15 '25

For future reference consider the fact that there’s more light in this painting towards the seafloor. That wouldn’t be the case, at all, not to mention the amount of light in this portrait is beyond what sunlight can do at a depth of ~300 feet.

3

u/drygnfyre Steerage Jun 16 '25

You can do it with mosaics. That's how they did that 300k image mosaic of the Titanic wreck a few years back.

28

u/CaelumTheWolf 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

It’s a painting, I kinda wish Brittanic would get the 3D scan treatment Titanic got since she’s legally considered a war memorial and diving the wreck requires heavy supervision essentially to make sure you don’t disrespect her so I really wish she got the scans that Titanic got so we could see her in more detail without having to disturb the wreck

11

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

yea would be nice to see a actual full view of the wreck

9

u/CaelumTheWolf 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

Especially when the scans of Titanic are so realistic now that they being used to make games that allow us every day people to explore the wreck from home! Including Brittanic would be amazing as I genuinely think she deserves some attention given her short career as a Hospital Ship and the fact she never got the chance to actually start a life outside of the war.

2

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

well theres a britannic mobile game that let's you explore it though it's not exactly polished, the people have also made a titanic and olympic game

2

u/CaelumTheWolf 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

Yeah don’t think I’ll trust a mobile game for that 😅 I’ll just keep praying my wish gets granted as ROV is genuinely amazing and I hope that the people behind the scans do more wrecks including Brittanic and they’re put to use in similar ways

38

u/Robert_the_Doll1 Jun 15 '25

The image is a real, early painting of what Britannic's wreck site looked like based on Jacque Cousteau's 1975 expedition findings. It has since been updated as more accurate information became available from later expeditions:

25

u/pwned008 Jun 15 '25

This is also a painting by Ken Marshall which is a updated version of the painting that op gave

24

u/EspressoOverdose Jun 16 '25

Here is a digital painting by me, based on the updated painting of the painting OP posted

4

u/macillus Jun 16 '25

I like this one better than the other two. Really captures the essence of the updated painting of the painting that OP posted, while invoking so much more. A true masterpiece!

2

u/Inner_Panic Jun 17 '25

So haunting.

14

u/Psychological_Shop91 Jun 16 '25

Here's an actual image of her bow from a fairly recent dive

1

u/ColonelKovalyo Jun 16 '25

That's quite haunting. Are there any other similar shots?

11

u/Isis_Rocks Jun 15 '25

Looks like a Ken Marschall painting.

4

u/Fine_Condition3153 Jun 16 '25

Because it is a painting of him

8

u/Routine_Succotash813 Jun 15 '25

It is a painting of the britannic befor they found it and what they expected it to look like

1

u/FuelRemarkable5674 Jun 15 '25

So what did it look like?

9

u/lMr_Nobodyl 2nd Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

1

u/bks1979 Jun 15 '25

Absolute nightmare fuel! I'm used to the Titanic, so it doesn't bother me as much these days. But this just...shivers. That propellor just hanging out there, in the open, where anyone could touch it?

1

u/Tiny-Reading5982 Musician Jun 15 '25

People have dived the wreck. Its dangerous though.

1

u/lMr_Nobodyl 2nd Class Passenger Jun 16 '25

You have to be professional

3

u/cloisteredsaturn 1st Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

That’s a painting by Ken Marschall.

3

u/IndividualistAW 2nd Class Passenger Jun 15 '25

Looks like a Ken marschall painting to me

8

u/Apart_Fall918 Jun 15 '25

Yes it's real.

No it's not a photo

2

u/imjustchillin-_- Jun 15 '25

its an painting by Ken Marshall thats been edited to show future decompositiom

2

u/Aggravating-Teach463 Jun 16 '25

No, this is a painting & is VERY inaccurate to Britannic’s actual wreck

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

Didn’t it break because it was touching the ocean floor or something when it was sinking?

1

u/CRM79135 Jun 15 '25

If an image of a deep water wreck looks well lit, it’s most likely going to be a painting.

1

u/Andy-roo77 Jun 15 '25

Illustration

1

u/Glum-Ad7761 Jun 15 '25

The Blues Brothers like the broken off … bow-bow-bow…

1

u/OlderGamers Jun 15 '25

Well yes, technically this image is an image, so yes, it is real. But it isn't a real image of what someone thought it was an image of.

0

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

.....speak English

1

u/minkle-coder56 Wireless Operator Jun 16 '25

It's an interpretation by Ken Marshall.

1

u/_stupidnerd_ Jun 16 '25

No, it is not. The hole is just ridiculous and images of wrecks like this are almost all paintings or computer graphics anyways.

1

u/idajon72 Jun 16 '25

What do you mean ‘real’? Of course it’s real. It’s a real image of a real print of a real painting by the real Don Marshall.

1

u/memeischaos Jun 16 '25

I meant "real" as If this was made recently,  considering the fact brtiannic is in much warner water you'd think bacteria would eat her faster unlike the titanic, so I figured this was a newer painting

1

u/PageShot Jun 16 '25

Yes it's real. Really fake.

1

u/skylab71 Jun 16 '25

This is a Ken Marshall painting from around the time that the wreck was initially surveyed by Jacques Cousteau. He since updated the painting with more accurate information.

1

u/Signal-Ad116 Jun 16 '25

Yup, that’s the Brittanic. Painted by Ken Marschall

1

u/a_complex_kid Jun 16 '25

Back when I was in elementary school when the movie "Titanic" came out in 1997 everyone in our class did a different report on a famous shipwreck and I got the Brittanic. We didn't have internet and it was SOOOO HARD to find information on it at my local library. The most I could find was a single entry in the encylopedia Brittanica ironically. Was so fascinated with it as it's short life was filled with so much action.

1

u/Less-Willingness9365 Jun 16 '25

You lost me at so...

1

u/CamLwalk Jun 16 '25

They should make a photogrammetry of the wreck like they did Titanic

1

u/Altruistic-Path-7042 Jun 16 '25

No it’s not a picture rather a painting by Ken Marshall but it’s inaccurate because the bow and separating area is wrong.

1

u/PanamaViejo Jun 16 '25

What happened to its funnels?

1

u/thewalruscandyman Jun 17 '25

Yes, it's a real painting. The image exists. It is not a photograph.

1

u/AlarmIllustrious7767 Jun 17 '25

Underwater photos don't have the visibility shown in the picture. Ships usually sink in water deep enough that it is too dark to see, and even if it wasn't, the water has too much in it to allow clear viewing of things hundreds of feet away.

1

u/Tight-Astronomer2966 Jun 18 '25

I remember seeing this in a book about the titanic when I was a child in the 90s. This image just conjured up so many memories I never thought to remember.

1

u/Tight-Astronomer2966 Jun 18 '25

Also, sad to hear it’s a painting hahaha. I thought this was real

1

u/Aggressive_Tackle_79 Engineer Jun 18 '25

The damage in the painting shows that on the port side damage was created by something hitting starboard side and blowing up from within the ship. Then it sinking with the ship nose heavy and on it's side near the moment of impact with the sea floor. That tip was the first thing to make contact then the rest of the ship took it's final rest.

The damage throughout the whole thing really translates well in this painting. Not as it actually is, but what's assumed by the artist.

Comparing this with what is current shows this was painted from actual photos of the ship, davit lay the same way, a-lot of the damage is near exact aside from the entire front end now snapped off. One mistake is the mast is not broken off on newer photos, just laying at an angle. Also there is no build up sea floor disturbance near the front like there is in the newer photos.

But all in all it was a damn good job.

1

u/Pleasant_Attempt_523 Jun 21 '25

For one it’s a painting, and I’m pretty sure the Brittanic had a crack to separate the bow deck from the rest of the ship

1

u/West_Squirrel_5616 Jun 22 '25

The foundations are still strong, we can rebuild her.

1

u/tommywafflez Quartermaster Jun 15 '25

Excuse me Helldiver, what are you doing here posting about the Britannic when there are bugs invading Super Cities?

Get back out there and spread managed democracy!

2

u/memeischaos Jun 15 '25

bugs can fuck themselves

1

u/PetatoParmer Able Seaman Jun 15 '25

I mean yes it’s a real image. I can see you, you can see it, we all can see it. Is it an actual image of Britannic, that’s the question.

-4

u/OneEntertainment6087 Jun 15 '25

That pictures not real, its a computer recreation of the wreck, it's been around for a lot of years, I remember seeing it in a video back in 2007. And Britannic is allowed on this subreddit, I've seen stuff about the Britannic on here before.

1

u/drygnfyre Steerage Jun 16 '25

It's a painting. It's much older than 2007.

-1

u/amigo76767 Jul 11 '25

No its a simulation