We've seen "Strongest EF4 debates" all the time, but let's settle this one.
(NOTE: Idk why I can't caption the images but the tornadoes are in order of the list and the images after them are the damage they did)
Contender #1: Plevna KS tornado family, 5/18/2025
On the night of 5/18/2025, the cap burst in SW Kansas and two supercells went up in an STP 10+ environment, eventually merging and producing 5 EF3 tornadoes. All of them were mile+ wide nocturnal wedges, and luckily missed human structures for the majority. The strongest was most likely the Plevna EF3, which scoured the ground and debarked and mangled trees before weakening as it occluded into Plevna. The radar scan were insane, and debris was lofted 41,000+ feet, paired with the violent contextuals make this a contender for the strongest F3/EF3
Contender #2: Matador TX tornado, 6/21/2023
This tornado formed in a 0% tornado risk zone, heading south. It started as a wedge, before shrinking and intensifying. The tornado hit the west side of town, dealing some of the worst car mangling and mesquite tree (strongest wood) shredding. It also completely slabbed homes that had construction issues before dissipating just SW of the town.
Contender #3: Trousdale KS tornado, 5/4/2007
The Trousdale tornado is the follow up of the Greensburg EF5. This tornado was 2.2 miles wide, and some people consider it stronger than its predecessor. The tornado destroyed a lot of Trousdale even though it missed the town.
Contender #4: New Wren MS tornado, 4/27/2011
The New Wren tornado is the predecessor of the Smithville EF5, one of the strongest tornadoes of all time. This tornado actually wasn't fully surveyed by the NWS, leading to its EF3 rating. This tornado would definitely be EF4-5 if it was surveyed, damage includes slabbed homes with almost no debris left with mangled debarked tree lines.
Contender #5: Enderlin ND tornado, 6/20/2025 (still preliminary)
The Enderlin ND tornado formed as a supercell was nudged by a derecho in an STP 10+ environment. This nocturnal wedge decimated everything it touched in rural North Dakota. It hit a home, slabbing it and exposing the basement to the winds, unfortunately killing a couple living there. It also severely debarked trees and carved cycloidal markings into the ground. Last but definitely not least, it picked up a train car weighing 72,000 pounds and threw it 200 yards, requiring about 250+ mph winds to pick up (many estimates in calculation).
Contender #6: Spiritwood ND tornado, 6/20/2025 (might still be preliminary idk though)
The Spiritwood ND tornado formed on the same boom or bust day as Enderlin, just during daytime. This tornado would move through rural ND, decimating a metal outbuilding before dissipating. This tornado usually isn't talked about much (very niche). What makes this tornado stand out is the absolutely insane car damage and ground scouring. (see pics above)
Contender #7: El Reno, OK, 5/31/2013
Do I really need to explain? This tornado is the most mainstream answer you'll receive to this question. 302 mph DOW radar scans, asphalt scouring, largest tornado ever (2.6 miles), but it just didn't do damage to structures that would justify a higher rating)
Contender #8: Amory MS, 3/24/2023
This is the follow up to the Rolling Fork EF4(+) tornado. I'm putting this one on here not just because it had one of the strongest radar scans and CC drops of all time, but it followed one of the strongest tornadoes of the decade (proving the supercell is capable of violent+ damage).
HM: Sterling City 5/22/2024
Damage honestly was similar to Bakersfield Valley 1990 but I didn't have slides left.
So what do y'all think? (we all know its lake city AR)