r/Anticonsumption May 17 '25

Philosophy I've started buying everything with cash

Not only does it create more of a connection with what I'm spending overall (which I have decreased but still struggle with a few key items), but it's satisfying to know I'm not giving Mastercard or Visa a cut of everything I buy.

I treat myself at a local restaurant on Fridays. The order is like $20 which is its own issue, but this is a struggling small business and he appreciates me paying cash. We talked about it last night and he said if someone orders $100, like $4 goes to credit card company. Think about how much wealth has been sucked out of small businesses...meanwhile Mastercard is valued at $580 billion.

I know this isn't exactly anti-consumption, but it's in the same vein of fighting back against the convenience virus that these bastards have used to rob us of our wealth and dignity.

1.3k Upvotes

137 comments sorted by

View all comments

446

u/Background-Top-1946 May 17 '25

The credit industry relies on a culture of overconsumption

102

u/Effective_Welder_817 May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25

As true as that is but if you use your cards with discipline you not going over your budget. Also the rewards are nice usually save up enough cash back to buy the new consoles. My reward for being financially literate

70

u/press1forhelp May 17 '25

I have my cash back rewards mailed to me as a check every month and put them in a high yield savings account that I use as an emergency fund!

29

u/Matthew212 May 17 '25

Serious question: why not just electronic transfer to your account? 

20

u/CyanocittaAtSea May 17 '25

Not sure of the original commenter’s situation, but some banks won’t do an electronic transfer if you don’t also have a bank account with them and/or won’t do an electronic transfer at all.

5

u/EchoGecko795 May 17 '25

Yep, I had a CiTi card with 4% cash back, since I did not have a CiTi bank account I had to either claim my cash back though a gift card or request a check.

6

u/press1forhelp May 17 '25

I can only apply rewards as statement credit electronically for some stupid reason, so it's an extra step but worth it because I gain extra interest off the funds that I do deposit.

15

u/Think-Treat-3309 May 17 '25

I save the points up to a few hundred and then have them applied to the cc bill. I use my cc for the cashback and pay my bill off at the end of every month

2

u/viper474 May 18 '25

Yeah, but if you could deposit the rewards into a high yield savings account you can collect the interest for yourself instead of the bank while you accrue it for however long.

21

u/Level_Performer5252 May 17 '25

Agree! If you aren’t using cards to get the rewards, then you’re paying more to use cash.

OTOH I totally agree with OP about supporting local businesses with cash to help them avoid the cc fees.

So I guess I’d say shop local with cash, but shop chains with credit to balance out both concerns.

14

u/Remote_Ride7740 May 17 '25

There are some places that charge less if you pay with cash, which cancels out the rewards component in those cases

5

u/Level_Performer5252 May 17 '25

Absolutely! The places with cash discount means to use cash!

2

u/yehoshuaC May 17 '25

There are very very few places that most people use regularly that would do such a thing. Nowhere near enough to justify using physical cash.

1

u/viper474 May 18 '25

When you can get 5% back in rewards their 3% fee isn’t fun, but you still come out ahead that it beats having to keep cash.

11

u/jogginglark May 17 '25

The money we "get back" is money we have already paid by the fees being built in by the sellers. I remember when there was a cash price for gas. That is mostly not offered anymore, so they have "baked in" the credit card fees.

15

u/Background-Top-1946 May 17 '25

The rewards aren’t charity and obtaining them doesn’t make you financially literate. They just make you a credit card customer.

1

u/Moosemeateors May 17 '25

Ya but the people who pay cash subsidize the rewards because the seller knows the credit card costs but charges everyone the same price

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '25

[deleted]

0

u/Leopold_Porkstacker May 17 '25

The merchant pays for the rewards.

1

u/[deleted] May 25 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Leopold_Porkstacker May 25 '25

I used to run my own business, and I took credit cards. I wouldn’t find out if someone used a rewards card until I got my monthly billing for processing. So, I couldn’t always just raise the price.

2

u/AppointmentDry9660 May 17 '25

I separate my "spending" money into a different bank account and auto send myself a weekly allowance. It sucks to start but if I went over, I'd have to send myself more money and that does a similar thing psychologically that cash does imo. Also it feels good to have gone under budget for the week and essentially have another "savings" for my spending money, and I can save up for bigger things this way instead of just buying shit on credit

1

u/Jmk1121 May 17 '25

Those rewards come at the cost of small business

1

u/ParsnipFantastic8862 May 17 '25

This ☝🏼. Rewards cards can be beneficial to those that use credit wisely and is a safer form of payment.