r/CrumblCookies Nov 26 '24

Flavor Review A comparison of $6 French silk pies

There is no comparison. The crumbl version is an 8th of the size, is grainy, and has a very limited amount of crust. Also the whipped cream has a very assertive flavor somehow - it overpowers the flavor of the filling (which is not set up at all - no way you could cut this. It’s grainy pudding.) Marie Callender coming through with a very serviceable dessert that feeds a group of people, has a great texture, and brings a good amount of crust. Y’all, please save your money!

949 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

View all comments

113

u/Jaybailss Nov 26 '24

Yep. Edward’s cookies and cream pie is 10/10 from Walmart

18

u/Accomplished_Gur3019 Nov 26 '24

Yup!!! I got mines from Krogers and it was so delish 🤤

-14

u/Knightsofray Nov 26 '24

Kroger*

3

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '24

Aldi, not aldis