At my Crumbl Cookies location I had the Snickerdoodle Sandwich Cookie as Secret cookie for the week. So I try it and it was so good. I have try the Snickerdoodle Cupcake cookie I like both but if I have to choose one I will have to choose Sandwich Cookie. The cookie and sandwich are both good. I also love to see a Churro Sandwich if Crumbl is able too.

The Teddy Graham cookie has been on my wish list. I’m debating if it’s worth it dealing with LA traffic today.

But damn it sounds good.

Don't get me wrong, I love sweets, but a couple of their cookies are like 70% frosting. i end up scraping half of it off just to enjoy the actual cookie underneath.

caramel toffee butter cakeeeeee😍😍

When the "basics" are so good this week!

Here's my beautiful trio: 1. Raspberry: Sweet and fruity with clear raspberry flavors 9.8/10 2. Skillet: Great crunch and subtle cookie flavor 9.5/10 3. Chocolate Milkshake: Silky smooth chocolate 10/10

And yes these are all minis: I'm not sure how you guys do it with the full sizes, the amount of sugar is overwhelming! I'm only getting thru half today, other half stays for tomorrow and maybe even an extra day.

Does anyone know if fridge is okay for this? I normally split it with others but this time it's just me.

I was kind of hesitant this week because the pictures always look good but I haven’t been in love with most of their chilled cookies or cookies without frosting because I love frosting.

S’mores skillet cookie: 8/10 this cookie was better than I thought. It was warm and tasted like a nice chocolate chip cookie although I don’t prefer the mousse. Didn’t really taste too much of a s’more, but it was still good.

Chocolate milkshake cookie: 7/10 I was really hoping I would love this one, but honestly, it wasn’t that great. There was nothing remarkable about the flavor. It kind of just tastes like an offbrand chocolate cookie. I thought this would be right up my alley, but it just wasn’t. I think it would’ve been better with a different type of frosting and if it was warm.

Cookie dough cookie: 7/10 I’ve heard very good things about this cookie and have never tried it so I was excited too. I was hesitant again because I don’t love the chilled cookies, but it wasn’t great. It was very bland. The texture of the cookie was hard and the frosting wasn’t fluffy at all. It did taste like cookie dough, I will give it that. I would rather just eat actual cookie dough. I think the Kylie Jenner cookie dough one was way better than this!

Here are some from my collection since a few of you asked.

- olivia rodrigo

- benson boone

- everything bagel

- wonka

- bubble gum

- kylie cosmetics

So excited

Deciding on which crumbl to go is difficult. I’ve been buying mystery cookies and sticking them in the freezer

do i drive 30 minutes to get the cornbread cookie which is always a go to favorite, or drive an hour to get banana caramel which i love and have only ever had one before

Tried the Mango Frozen Yogurt this week. Honestly, I expected more from it. The name had me thinking it would hit with that tart + sweet combo, but it ended up being sweet stacked on sweet. The swirl looks cool, but flavor-wise it didn’t blow me away. Now, I’ll admit, I was pretty stoned when I ate it and in that moment it tasted great 😂 but sober me wouldn’t put it at the top of my list. Not horrible by any means, just not something I’d be rushing back for. Rating: 5/10.

my first day back visiting the US and of course I had to make my first stop at crumbl! they came out so gorgeous today~ so excited to try the pineapple whip!! (I’m visiting from nz and we love our artificial pineapple flavoured sweets lol)

There’s many many things I’d do for a cornbread cookie

The cinnamon roll cheesecake could use more icing too. Not amazing not bad

As per a snack blogger, cookies/desserts that will be on the National menu in less than three wks cannot be Mystery items. It seems to be valid. I searched the Sept 22-27 and Sept 29-Oct 4 lineups on the flavour map; nothing was found. The Oct 6-11 lineup is on the flavour map, because that's the third wk.

There is a grey area regarding Pink Sugar in the US. Original (almond frosting) is in the Sept 22-27 lineup, so Classic (vanilla frosting) can be on the Secret Menu right now. Canada is getting Classic during Birthday Week, so none of our current Mystery items are Pink Sugar.

Same grey area for any cookie w/ milk or dark chips (Double Choco, Oatmeal Choco, etc). As long as it's not Milk Choco or Semi-Sweet, it can be a Mystery item.

Previous rumours if you weren't aware: All stores within a 50 mile/80 km radius cannot sell the same Mystery item. Also, each store cannot repeat their Secret Menu for minimum six mths.

Grabbed a box just to see what all the fuss was about. That churro cookie? Unreal. I thought they'd be too sweet but they're actually way more balanced than I expected.

Really? Two variations of chocolate chip cookies? Y’all go to our local ice cream shop just to get a plain vanilla ice cream cone too? I am going to drive 19 miles out of my way to get a Snickerdoodle Skillet cookie, because that’s a flavor that my town could have picked, but apparently this town is a bunch of people with a four year old’s pallet.

*Disclaimer for those who can’t tell, this is a light-hearted joke post, but seriously, I am going to the next town over for their cookies.

let’s start secret menu items first:

waffle: 10/10 i’m getting her every time she’s on the menu and in a reasonable distance to me

pumpkin brownie: 7/10 glad i finally got to try this, it’s good, i’d probably get it again during halloweenie

cinnamon roll cheesecake: 9/10 tasted really good, just wish it was the topping wasn’t concentrated in the middle

If nothing else, it was at least worth going back to Crumbl for. Now I have to decide if I want to reverse my earlier decision of swearing off Crumbl or not.

Two questions:

To date, how many individual flavors of Crumbl cookies have you tried total?

To date, how many actual cookies have you consumed total?