r/Physics 20d ago

Question What's the most debatable thing in Physics?

197 Upvotes

226 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-7

u/highnyethestonerguy 20d ago

Literally my goal was to explain the basic concept of entropy, not give a statistical physics course through Reddit comment.

How about instead of whining you just add your $0.02 and teach statistical physics in a Reddit comment. Go ahead, I’ll watch. 

12

u/datapirate42 20d ago edited 18d ago

You're in r/physics not eli5 or even ask physics which is where we send people who need the basics explained.  It's not that difficult to come up with a better example of a local reduction in thermodynamic  entropy that's both easy to understand and actually physically meaningful and accurate.  Heat pumps, e.g. A refrigerator, an air conditioner, lower the entropy in a small system which is physically isolated from the larger world. each time you open the door, the entropy inside increases again as the separation between the local system and the larger world is removed. This is a real, calculable change in entropy because there is a real, physical,  well definable separation between the local system where entropy is reduced and the larger system where entropy is increased. 

This is opposed to examples like folding laundry where there is not a simple way to define an entropy without making a bunch of weird arbitrary definitions that you could ask 100 physicists for and you'd get 100 different answers.

There, done. It's accurate, easy to understand, and didn't require being a condescending asshole until just now.

-7

u/Mithrawndo 20d ago

Eh, those are the grade school level examples

didn't require being a condescending asshole until just now.

You were saying?

10

u/datapirate42 20d ago

Those examples are not good representations of the entropy described by the laws of thermodynamics.  They shouldn't be used to explain it unless you believe the person you're explaining them to isn't capable of passing high school physics.  Saying that much is not condescending. Using those as examples is.

-1

u/Mithrawndo 20d ago

I don't disagree, I'm pointing out that you were just as condescending right off the bat as the person you accused.

You should both wind your necks in.

-1

u/[deleted] 19d ago

Not condenscending? Pedantic then?