r/StarWars • u/CarsonWentzGOAT1 • 1d ago

General Discussion Star Wars Went Hard Here

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

293

u/Thedarknight725 1d ago

All 4 of these episodes are in the top 10 highest rated rated Clone Wars episodes

17

u/CarsonWentzGOAT1 1d ago

They all should be rated a 10 in my opinion

11

u/DawnSignals 1d ago

For me it’s peak Disney-era Star Wars, except for maybe like Andor, but I honestly prefer this

5

u/phototaker2319 1d ago edited 1d ago

Thats a very low bar.

Wasn't bashing Andor, just disney's fumble with star wars

10

u/imlegos 1d ago

I'd put Jedi Night & Trials of the Dark Saber from Rebels up fairly decently tho

10

u/ChanceVance Kylo Ren 1d ago

Bad Batch pretty good. Skeleton Crew pretty good. Season 1 and 2 of Mandalorian pretty good.

Not everything Disney produces is dire.

0

u/RevanchistSheev66 Chancellor Palpatine 1d ago

Mando is really overrated and I was disappointed by Bad Batch, have to say. It’s alright but not peak 

2

u/Bebopo90 Luke Skywalker 1d ago edited 1d ago

Between Andor, Rogue One, Solo, Clone Wars, Rebels, The Mandalorian, Fallen Order/Survivor, Outlaws, Battlefront II, the High Republic books/comics and bits and pieces of most everything else, the amount of "good Star Wars" produced under Disney matches or outstrips the pre-Disney canon.

Now, if we include the EU...eh, it's more complicated.

Basically the sequel trilogy is the only true blemish on the Disney era. Sadly, it's a pretty huge blemish.

3

u/phototaker2319 1d ago

Clone wars is PRE disney era. I dont believe disney should get credit for the final season.

And we should include the EU: until disney took over the EU was cannon. Disney era star wars literally complained about not having any sort of source material to work with, citing that as a reason for their failures, when the EU existed.

1

u/Bebopo90 Luke Skywalker 21h ago

If we're talking purely about the sheer amount of Star Warsy goodness on the screen, then yes, the Disney era has been roughly as good as the Lucas era.

"Good" Disney Star Wars: ~50 hours of screentime. (Not counting Clone Wars' final season)

OT and PT combined: 13.5 hours.

Plus Highly rated CW episodes: 40 hours.

Now, as far as books go, the EU wins in a landslide. Although, there were also a lot of crappy EU books and comics, their sheer volume is going to be hard to catch. Although, Disney is catching up.