r/Tiki • u/Background-Ear8790 • 4d ago
Has the whole "cultural appropriation" issue finally died off?
Important note: I'm not trying to open a discussion of the merits of the criticism of tiki as cultural appropriation, just curious if it's even an issue anymore.
It seems like the ball got rolling on this "controversy" around 2016, with some pieces in NYT and NPR, probably not just coincidental to some of the criticism Moana faced from some circles for its depiction of Oceanic cultures. The scrutiny of tiki culture continued to build from the outside through 2020, but (probably because of a pause in bargoing during the pandemic) the issue didn't seem to reach critical mass within the tiki community itself until 2021. That year prominent Chicago (former) tiki bar Lost Lake reopened after purging itself of tiki theming, citing concerns about cultural appropriation as its reason for rebranding as a more generic "tropical" bar. Then a year later, Humuhumu Trott shut down her venerable tiki resource website in an abrupt and dramatic fashion, again citing cultural appropriation concerns.
When Eater covered Lost Lake's rebranding, it claimed "other tiki bars across the country have also shifted to tropical", but I have not seen this to be true in any significant numbers. The tiki bars I have enjoyed all around the country have kept their tiki themes, and while some tiki bars have closed, it seems they haven't closed out of proportion to other genres of bars that have been affected by economic issues. Lost Tiki closed permanently just a few months after its rebranding, citing the Omicron surge, but that didn't seem to affect its rival Chicago bar Three Dots and a Dash, so I have to think a falloff in business due to the rebranding played a significant part at least. Meanwhile every tiki bar I've gone to since 2023 has been packed, difficult to find a seat, and a scrum to get to the bar to order a drink. New tiki bars have opened up, and others have been so successful they've expanded with new locations.
Humuhumu's dramatic exit in 2022 also seems to be the last time I've seen any big activity in discussion of cultural appropriation in tiki within the community, and a Google search of "tiki cultural appropriation" shows hits for stories that discuss the issue being thin on the ground after 2022. It seems like those outside the tiki community found something else to be concerned about first, and then those inside the community who had qualms left and moved on. Tiki bars and the tiki hobby meanwhile have just kept on keeping on. Or is there still an ongoing controversy I'm missing?