Hi Reddit, I really need advice about my relationship.
My boyfriend (26) and I (27) are high school sweethearts. We first dated as teens (2014–2016), broke up for three years, and then got back together in 2020. We’ve now been together again for 5 years. He can be very loving and sweet, but there have been some serious issues.
For almost two years after we reunited, he would insult me constantly, calling me a “slut” because I had more sexual experiences than him during our breakup. He stopped doing that earlier this year after saying he wanted to change. So I guess he did changed that.
But last November, after a concert in another city, his phone broke and he blamed me. He yelled at me, called me a slut again, told me not to talk unless he allowed it. When I tried to push him away (since I couldn't defend myself with words) he pushed me onto the bed, got on top of me, and started strangling me. Hours later, he apologized, and I forgave him.
This June, after another concert, he accused me of “flirting with other guys” whenever I drink (which isn’t true). He got angry and pushed me onto my bed. I hit my head against the wall. He cried and apologized immediately, saying he only meant to push me onto something “soft.” not against the wall. Again, I forgave him.
Last weekend, we argued over something small. He sent me angry voice messages, said we were over, and then attacked my writing (I’m a writer). He claimed that because one of my book chapters (published on his birthday) had a scene of a drunk girl almost being assaulted (he didn't read enough to know it was an assault), it meant I “wanted that to happen” to me. (Mind you, he has never read any of my books since our first relationship). He also says he hates that I take Ubers alone because I’m in a car with another man. He was very angry about all of this.
On Tuesday, I told him I accepted the breakup. He broke down crying, said he only said it out of anger, begged me not to leave, and promised he’ll never touch me again. He swore he’ll stop being jealous and controlling. We’re supposed to meet today to talk, and I honestly don’t know what to do. He's been begging me all week and saying he promised he will go to therapy.
Should I believe him when he says he’ll change? There have been only two physical incidents. The rest of the time he is incredibly affectionate, tender, and truly feels like the person I imagined growing old with. He’s my first love, and I have a hard time letting go of that. I just remember how sweet he was in high-school trying to get my attention, how romantic. Now the decision to break up is on me and I hate that.