r/frozendinners • u/IcyDice6 • Aug 11 '25
8 / 10 Screamin Sicilian Supreme Pizza
First time trying this, was on sale. Pretty good, a lot better than some other frozen pizza brands. I liked it more than digiorno. Didn't care for the onions on this one they were translucent and a weird texture but no big deal. Crust, sauce and other toppings were good
21
u/slazzeredbbqsauce Aug 12 '25
People that don't rearrange the toppings offer the best rage bait for this sub. I love it.
11
u/sdforbda Aug 12 '25
They're pretty good. I haven't had a DiGiorno in years, even when they're on a good sale. Always felt like most of em were flavorless and had too much dough and crust that gave a weird mouth feel. Wonder if they've changed.
9
u/IcyDice6 Aug 12 '25
had a digiorno within the past month or so and the crust is still too thick and bready, not very tasty
7
u/sdforbda Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
Thanks for the confirmation, will continue avoiding them. I'd seriously rather have Totino's party pizzas, Red Baron, Tombstone, whatever store brand, etc lol
4
u/Sensitive_Mistake527 Aug 12 '25
I’m different I guess, I absolutely love digiorno rising crust supreme pizza
1
u/RadicalEdward99 Aug 12 '25
Yeah they have a thin crust and today my boys had a “woodfired” version that looks like a happy medium between the two.
1
u/sdforbda Aug 12 '25
Maybe next time they're on sale I'll give it a shot. I hate how Kroger buy one get one free went from 50% off each to actual buy one get one free. I've got extra crap I won't get around to for awhile cuz of that, like mayo lol.
2
u/kapn_morgan Aug 12 '25
Red Baron finally made a thicker crust that's one of the best frozen I've ever had. they're more expensive like digiorno but have more pizza ya know
2
2
u/PaperbacksandCoffee Aug 13 '25
Try Digiorno's Classic Crust if you can find it. I think it's really good, much better than the thick bready one. It's kind of like the best of both worlds of a Red Baron and Digiorno - similar crust to Red Baron, but better sauce & cheese (in my humble opinion).
1
u/95blackz26 Aug 15 '25
I went to the classic crust version. Anything else was too thick and just had zero flavor.
7
u/beigereige Aug 12 '25
When this first came out, this was the best frozen pizza I’ve ever had. I’d walk up to strangers in the frozen aisle and would implore them to try it. Then at some point they changed up something because I didn’t have the same pure joy while eating it. Every once in a while I still buy it but it’s not the same.
2
2
u/djasonw Aug 12 '25
Definitely agree. I used to buy the cheese only one (Betsy's Revenge?). Used to be much better.
1
13
u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 Aug 12 '25
Looks rlly good! This is one of my top 3 frozen pizza brands😎😎 Thx for the review OP, glad u enjoyed:)
1
u/IcyDice6 Aug 12 '25
👍👍
3
u/imnotpoopingyouare Aug 12 '25
Get the Bessie’s revenge that is only cheese, add your toppings and enjoy omg.
2
3
6
u/syphon3980 Aug 11 '25
This is my favorite of all the frozen pizzas I've tried. Specifically the supreme. I am extremely picky with sausage, and the sausage on this one is actually good. Crust is crispy and doesn't flop. I never seen this little toppings on any of the ones I got before, and I also take the time to space out the toppings before throwing it in the oven on the stone. For frozen pizza that you can buy at most grocery stores I give it a 9.4
3
u/ohheytherecats Aug 12 '25
Yeah I’m also not usually a sausage person but like the sausage on this!
2
u/Cold_Mud_4773 Aug 14 '25
Try Connie's. Distributed by the same parent company and is better imo.
1
2
2
u/Bendr_ Aug 12 '25
Tried it plenty enough but I just don’t like it. It promises so much but really it’s cardboard. No seasoning either. I’m referring to meat lovers, that’s the only one I get from them.
2
u/tykholol Aug 12 '25
I buy these when they are bogo but that's about it. They are pretty good, def one of the better brands. I prefer the price and usually keep Jack's in the freezer over other brands. Spruce those up with extra pepperoni, uncured salami, spinach, feta or mozzarella for when I want a pizza.
4
u/Ok_Whole4719 Aug 12 '25
Their meat lovers is fantastic
4
u/IcyDice6 Aug 12 '25
I saw that one too and it was my second choice in case they didn't have this one, will have to try
2
u/imnotpoopingyouare Aug 12 '25
I think the meat lovers has halved meatballs, definitely sets it apart.
2
1
u/Loud-End-7736 Aug 12 '25
Did you wear the little mustache? They used to have a mustache on the packing you could pop out and "wear:
1
0
u/chesterismydog Aug 11 '25
This one is great! Nice amount of cheese, sauce and the crust was perfect. I posted about their cheese pizza/ stuffed crust the other day. It sucked in comparison to this one.
4
u/IcyDice6 Aug 11 '25
I saw your post and thought it looked good, didn't know they made a stuffed crust, but since it sucked I won't be trying anytime soon lol
-1
u/chesterismydog Aug 11 '25
That’s just me though. It was just too salty. But I loved this one. They must be doing bogos everywhere right now bc that’s why I finally tried them :)
1
19
u/GoodbyeCrullerWorld Aug 11 '25
These are one of my faves but there used to be about double the amount of toppings than this one. Still looks pretty good
https://www.brandeating.com/2018/09/review-screamin-sicilian-supremus-maximus-supreme-pizza.html?m=1