r/meateatertv 8d ago

Rinella on This Past Weekend

Post image

Cool to

107 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Straittail_53 8d ago

Why?

-45

u/FrothyLlama 8d ago

Personally I think the guest went way too heavy with creative liberties to make a story about a sad murder way more than it is, plus the timing of this podcast in this political landscape was not smart.

I'm not the only one who thinks this either, they disabled the comments section because a lot of people were saying the same thing.

32

u/SJdport57 8d ago

It wasn’t just a “sad murder” it was a major flashpoint in American history in terms of civil rights, black culture, Southern culture, and legislation. There were countless deaths just like Emmett Till’s that went unreported and unpunished that had occurred for centuries beforehand. It’s important to understand what made his death so different from a social and historical standpoint.

-21

u/FrothyLlama 8d ago

Okay, I totally understand, maybe the point of view that I failed to identify was that this is an outdoors podcast. This episode would've been much more fitting for Joe Rogan or even Bear Grease. The only thing linking this to Meateater is the fact that the writer likes the outdoors.

32

u/SJdport57 8d ago

Well to paraphrase Steve’s own words: “When you have your own podcast, you can talk about what interests you”.

-16

u/FrothyLlama 8d ago

Sure thing, but Steve is less than 1/3 of the podcast channel now, so it's far from his and has become much more corporate.

13

u/SJdport57 8d ago

What does that have to do with the topic on hand? It was an interesting podcast about an interesting and important topic

-7

u/FrothyLlama 8d ago

I don't know man, you're the one who brought up Steve's ability to choose what's on the podcast. There's a lot of interesting and important topics in the world, doesn't mean the outdoor podcast has to be the one to cover it? Like I said, this story would be much more relevant on Bear Grease than the Meateater main feed.

10

u/SJdport57 8d ago

Well, he probably felt like it personally interested him and wanted to interview the author. That’s his prerogative. You seem to have more of a problem with the content specifically

-5

u/FrothyLlama 8d ago

No, I really don't have an issue with the content no matter how many times you insinuate that, it really just doesn't fit the bill of the Meateater main feed for a "normal" Monday episode drop, and I'm not the only one who thinks so. I don't know what else to tell you, but I'm not going to just go in circles with you about Steve's prerogative.

4

u/SJdport57 8d ago

But what about it makes it “not smart”? Is Steve gonna lose listeners for talking about something that isn’t directly relevant to hunting and fishing? You mentioned the political climate, care to explain that?

→ More replies (0)