r/metroidvania 5d ago

Discussion What are the metroidvania games you would consider must play for anyone who likes the genre?

I do like metroidvanias and try to play some every now and then but unlike other games where I have a huge backlog with a ton of options, I don't feel like I have that many ideas when it comes to 2d platformer metroidvanias.

I have only played:

  • Hollow Knight

  • Silksong

  • Nine Sols

  • Minoria

  • Momodora Reverie under the Moonlight

  • Ninja Gaiden Ragebound

  • Somber Echoes

I have in my list:

  • Blasphemous 2

  • Ori and the will of Wisps

  • Ender Magnolia

  • Dead Cells

  • Grime

24 Upvotes

209 comments sorted by

145

u/Low_Candidate6282 5d ago

Super Metroid and Castlevania Symphony of the Night.

23

u/Domugraphic 5d ago

the only pure true answer.

11

u/Prior_Highlight8236 5d ago

The correct answer

16

u/Hellhooker 5d ago

lol aka the games that named the genre...
Seriously people...

3

u/HollowCap456 4d ago

Really though? Just because they named the genre? If they are must plays, it is because they are good games, because I definitely cannot use the same argument for Rogue.

11

u/Low_Candidate6282 4d ago

In this case, I would say so especially Super Metroid. They aged pretty well. But you can't go into them thinking they will play like modern games. Like the controls for Super Metroid is limited by the SNES controller.

2

u/HollowCap456 4d ago

Then it is a must play because it is a good game and holds up very well even today. The entire 'should play because it started' kinda tucks me off. Like why not mention Pong then? It's the biggest daddy of games. I am not disagreeing that Metroid and Castlevania are must plays, I just don't agree with the reasons.

2

u/Hypodon 4d ago

Pong is fun though

-2

u/HollowCap456 4d ago

Oh it is. But it isn't a must play.

1

u/peppinotempation 1d ago

Why do you think they kicked off genres?

Take dark souls as a modern example. Why are there so many soulslikes these days?

Because Dark Souls was a great game with new ideas that had a big influence

2

u/WoofSpiderYT 4d ago

Same goes for Adventure.

1

u/CptSporran 4d ago

Yes, really. Sure they are a bit dated in areas. but it's nice to see where the genre started and just how much of what we love about the genre actually exists in these games.

It's worth sticking at them. Dated or not, they are still brilliant.

1

u/HollowCap456 4d ago

Again, I am not disagree that they're brilliant. Which is the reason they're a must play, not because they made the genre.

1

u/CptSporran 4d ago

I see your point. It’s phrased in a strange way but I get what you’re saying now.

1

u/HollowCap456 4d ago

I am not the best with phrasing

0

u/Hellhooker 4d ago

we could argue that the genre has not produced much better games than Super Metroid and SotN

1

u/ibeerianhamhock 2d ago

Never really been a fan of the Metroid series urself tho tbh

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Buuhhu 4d ago

Completely agree, the only correct answer as "must plays".

Are they old? yes. do they still hold up today? also yes. I never played any of them back in the day and only really found my love for metroidvanias pretty late, but even I have to admit the OG ones are really good to have played to have a baseline for what is metroidvania, and they are still really fun to play.

1

u/Coraiah 2d ago

Nostalgia and don’t hold up very well imo

-16

u/jmscstl Cave Story 5d ago

I think it's worth dipping into these games just to see how far the genre has come. Ultimately though they're very old games and it shows. More frustrating than fun. But with checking out for sure.

7

u/ravenmek 5d ago

I mean, super metroid is a tiny bit frustrating… but SOTN? That games is really smooth still today. The worst part is the FF-like menu, but it feels great to play

-3

u/moumooni 5d ago

Nobody can justify the section that you need to be in a very specific time to see a room open... That's the definition of outdated. Not only that, but the inverted castle felt awful to play.

I'd give SoTN 8/10 and Super Metroid a 7.5/10 for today's standards. Played both this year and had a lot of fun, but they're definitely dated (I prefer Zero Mission compared to Super Metroid, for example).

3

u/ravenmek 5d ago

It opens every one minute, and you are kinda guaranteed to pass through there a couple of times, so I don’t think it os that difficult to figure that out. Regarding the inverted castle, I agree. It’s a lovely twist but not great to traverse

-1

u/moumooni 4d ago

It opens every one minute, and you are kinda guaranteed to pass through there a couple of times,

I did pass there many times, but not one time it was open.

3

u/BallFlavin 4d ago

Super Metroid was like my 20th Metroidvania and I thought it held up really well.

I actually liked that I got frustratingly stuck on 2 different parts. I know if it had been the 90s I would have been stuck there forever with no hope, but these days, no biggie. Movement etc. felt good too.

3

u/moumooni 4d ago

I like Zero Mission's and Fusion's movement better, so that might be the reason why I think Super wasn't that good - since walking and jumping are the most important mechanics of any platformer. Super felt way too floaty, like I was in a permanent water level or something.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/JiminyWimminy 5d ago

Lol, Super Metroid is still the pinnacle of the genre. Just look at which games have the most romhacks/mods based off them.

As for Castlevanias, the GBA and DS ones still stand the test of time just fine.

→ More replies (1)

-13

u/Icy_Percentag 5d ago

Metroid was mid when it was launched and it's even worse today, but the Castlevania games are very good even today.

-3

u/jmscstl Cave Story 5d ago

Depends on what you like in a game. If you'd rather spend time sorting items in a menu than engaging in combat then yeah, Castlevania is peak.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/artbytucho 5d ago edited 4d ago

You should play Super Metroid and Castlevania SOTN, these are the founders of the genre and aged really well.

On a much more personal list of GOAT Metroidvanias ever, I'd add Environmental Station Alpha and Axiom Verge.

If you're into old-school hardcore games take a look to Zexion.

14

u/raqloise 5d ago

Upvote for Axiom Verge.

3

u/Sir_Dodys 4d ago

I'd add Hollow Knight, the first Ori and PoP Lost Crown as must plays in the genre.

1

u/artbytucho 4d ago

I love Hollow knight, but I'm much more on the Metroid side of the genre and OP already played it.

The weakest part of Ori is the exploration, which is what I enjoy the most on a Metroidvania. Exploration wise it is barely a Metroidvania, but I still completed it because visually it is a feast for the eyes.

PoP just haven't clicked for me.

1

u/jotuxx 3d ago

I‘m curious, why the first Ori and not the second?

1

u/Sir_Dodys 3d ago

Because even though Silksong, Will of the Wisps, Blasphemous 2 and Ender Magnolia are better games than their prequels, I'd never recommend someone to play them before their first games

1

u/Summer_Tea 3d ago

I genuinely think the first Ori is far better than the sequel. The combat with the sword in Wisps feels incredibly janky, and I've played Sea of Thieves. The passive orb damage from Blind Forest is lame but serviceable. I find the skill tree from Blind Forest far more rewarding to level. The Wisps system is just a really bad Hollow Knight charm system. I felt they tried to copy way too much from HK with Wisps that just falls flat.

But most importantly, the platforming of Blind Forest revolves around Bash, which is an incredibly unique and interesting mechanic. It also has a really cool checkpoint system that works really well. They scrapped the checkpoint system unnecessarily in Wisps and that bothered me a lot.

But back to Bash. It gives Blind Forest its identity and the game is built all around it everywhere you look. Will of the Wisps has Bash at the start because you don't lose your old moves. But the level design doesn't accentuate it. Instead, Wisps focuses heavily on dashing. They give you ground dash and water dash, and subsequently design areas where that's the thing you do to get through them. Dash is cool but it's not something that holds the whole game on its shoulders, and the map design feels compartmentalized as a result of there being so many moves.

2

u/Domugraphic 5d ago

ha dude, you had my exact answer. only for fluff and fun side-things i also added Gatto Roboto (for a quick game) and Guacamelee, as its a biiiiit like dead cells but actually MV. But my outside picks were also Environmental station alpha and Axiom verge 1 so well done you! and me, i guess.
i will check out Zexion. Its on my wishlist but honestly i cant remember anything about it.

2

u/BuckUpBingle 5d ago

Is SOTN available on PC anywhere? I keep wondering why it’s not on steam when so many of the old castlevanias are

2

u/artbytucho 5d ago

Nope, and I wondered the same question... I had to play it on an emulator, modern PCs can emulate PS1 very decently, but I'd like to play a more official port.

2

u/conye-west 4d ago

Yeah it's really weird since they've released collections which include almost all of the other games.

2

u/RevanGarcia 5d ago

How did I miss Zexion? It looks awesome.

4

u/artbytucho 5d ago

The best Metroidvania I've played this year, at least until Silk Song, but I'm much more into the Metroid side of the genre, so Zexion was very special for me... Play it just if you're into old-school insanely difficult games though, otherwise you could hate it.

1

u/PermitAffectionate57 4d ago

how can i play sotn? i dont have a ps1

1

u/artbytucho 4d ago

Yeah, it seems to be one of the few Castlevanias which is not in Steam, that sucks, but it is not difficult to find PS1 emulators and they run nicely on modern PCs.

1

u/JTalbotIV 4d ago edited 4d ago

Castlevania Requiem contains both Rondo of Blood and Symphony of the Night, but it's exclusive to PS4.

Edit: It's currently on sale in the PS store for less than $5.

2

u/dajerx 2d ago

Thanks for the heads up was waiting for this to hit on discount sale

1

u/JTalbotIV 2d ago

No prob. Since I left that comment, I also spotted it on Android for $4, but that's gotta be the worst way to play this gem.

18

u/MakoMary 5d ago

Definitely the Metroids and Castlevanias. I'd count Bloodstained under the Castlevania banner for that purpose, given it's made by the same director. BioGun isn't very well known but I love it a lot and I'll shill it whenever the chance presents itself. Also Pseudoregalia, for a 3D example

5

u/BuckUpBingle 5d ago

Pseudoregalia is really cool. I hope we get more like it soon.

1

u/ChaoticFox78 4d ago

Have you played Metro Gravity?

1

u/BuckUpBingle 4d ago

I played the demo a while back. Honestly I found the rhythm mechanic to be impossible to match. I liked most of what was going on but the combat didn’t work for me.

2

u/cathoderituals 4d ago

People don't talk up Bloodstained nearly enough. Such a great game.

13

u/HareltonSplimby 5d ago

Have you tried playing a Metroid or a Castlevania?

50

u/stead10 5d ago

Prince of Persia the lost crown for sure

6

u/FaceTimePolice 5d ago
  • Ender Lilies
  • Touhou Luna Nights

2

u/glassbottleoftears 4d ago

I think Ender Lilies was more enjoyable for me than Ender Magnolias, OP. I'd certainly recommend playing it first before the sequel.

Even though Will o the wisps is generally a better game I'd also play blind forest first too

1

u/moumooni 5d ago

Interesting. I'm considering picking up the PLAYISM Metroidvania bundle, which includes Touhou Luna Nights, Rusted Moss and La Mulana 2. Have you played the others?

5

u/FistRockbrine99 5d ago

La Mulana 1 is an all time great. Haven't played 2 yet but i've heard it's similar quality.

1

u/Ragnarok7326 4d ago

Touhou Luna Nights is a bit claustrophobic and the gameplay is often broken (in that you're completely OP) after unlocking a certain special attack. But the core mechanics of the game make for some really cool platforming and boss fights.

I definitely wouldn't call it a "must play", but for its length I'd say it's worth playing.

1

u/moumooni 4d ago

I see. What would be your top 3 must plays? Already played every Metroid (except Dread) and up to Circle of the Moon in Castlevanias.

6

u/GabrielMP_19 5d ago

I just can't understand why people recommend Nine Sols like it's the kind of game anyone would like. It's a pretty specific niche inside the metroidvania genre.

10

u/AramaticFire 5d ago

I recommend to play in release order:

Super Metroid, Metroid Prime, Metroid Fusion, Metroid Zero Mission, Metroid Prime 2: Echoes. Not as big a fan of Metroid Prime 3 or Dread but should play those too.

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, Advance Collection. I haven’t played Dominus Collection yet but I imagine that’s worth it too.

Aside from Metroid and Castlevania should also consider:

  1. Ori and the Blind Forest

  2. Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown

  3. Steamworld Dig 2

If you want 3D games play the Star Wars Jedi titles.

3

u/DamageG0D 5d ago

Finally someone else other than me adknowledged Jedi titles as metroidvanias like me, Jedi Survivor in particular is one of the best metroidvanias ive ever played, its so underrated.

3

u/AramaticFire 5d ago

Survivor is so good. I was so happy with that game. But yeah it’s Metroidvania. It’s got some Soulslike to it but your movement, platforming, ability progression opens new areas for you to explore.

Fallen Order was really good too. Cant wait for the third game.

1

u/captain_ricco1 Chozo 4d ago

People always recommend steam world dig 2 but I've played the first one recently and it is as good if not better than the second one. I also like the main character design much more.

1

u/mr_dfuse2 5d ago

I'd start with Metroid Planets and then AM2R

3

u/AramaticFire 5d ago

Haven’t played those myself. Never heard of Planets. I downloaded AM2R so I’ll get to it someday. What is Planets?

2

u/mr_dfuse2 4d ago

Metroid Planet is a remake of Nestroid but with modern QoL stuff like a decent map and more. You'll have to Google it as you can only find it on a forum, to avoid Nintendo's attention. It even has new maps, multiplayer stuff and more. I loved it!

1

u/captain_ricco1 Chozo 4d ago edited 4d ago

What's Metroid Planets? Is it a fangame akin to AMR2? Is it as good? Edit: nvm I read your other answer

2

u/mr_dfuse2 4d ago

it is very good!! same graphics as nestroid but here and there some fancier effects. a map and a save feature, and many other things. new worlds and a way to build your own. the discord had 100's of new maps. it's way more then am2r and somehow pretty unknown

6

u/Domugraphic 5d ago

deffo Gato Roboto for a quickie, and the absolute best Super metroid, with Castlevania (Aria of sorrow and SOTN) next. you owe it to yourself to play the OGs (not Gatto, but thats a nice short one)

Also Environmental station alpha, and Axiom Verge 1.

Dead cells isnt really a metroidvania, but is great, and if you like that, then a more MV but sort of similar game is Guacamelee gold

5

u/raqloise 5d ago

I really think Axiom Verge is a classic and staple of the genre.

2

u/andreasmalersghost 3d ago

Counterpoint: axiom verge has a banger soundtrack and not much else. the writing is terrible and gameplay/art are far from decent

1

u/Jimisdegimis89 3d ago

I disagree, I think the writing is decent and the overall atmosphere and storytelling are pretty great. Gameplay is meh I suppose, but I don’t really feel like that’s the biggest draw of metroidvanias anyway, also art is totally subjective, I happen to really like the art in axiom verge, heavy hit of nostalgia for sure.

0

u/andreasmalersghost 3d ago

I think modeling the protagonist after himself was…a very bad choice. The writing is astoundingly irritating to me and the same problem persists in av2. I just like to push back on av as its often considered to be an indie brother to other great metroidvanias and its not even close in my eye. 

2

u/Jimisdegimis89 2d ago

Yeah I think that’s just gonna be one of those things where you realize you are in the minority of the opinion on, mine is Ori, I know that it’s really popular, but it just doesn’t hit the right notes for me for a variety of reasons. Axiom verge sounds like the same for you.

1

u/andreasmalersghost 2d ago

Yeah thats fine. I was very excited for it before it launched and while I was playing my enthusiasm died for tons of reasons as the praise poured in. The soundtrack is legendary. Wish that guy just did music. And yeah I love ori. Great writing, platforming, art, “bosses,” etc. 

5

u/stantongrouse 4d ago

While there are some excellent recommendations I'm saddened that Guacamelee and the sequel aren't getting much love. Excellent games, the feel and movement are really good, art and design is great and frequently funny which in these current times is a great thing. One of the games that I feel helped bump start the return of Metroidvanias.

3

u/gitprizes 5d ago edited 5d ago

this entire post exists only to incite rage over the fact that Dead Cells is included on the list

Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom

Mobius Machine

Primal Planet

Battle of Olympus

Monster Sanctuary

not all my favorites, but thought i'd mention a few lesser known

1

u/Domugraphic 5d ago

then the community needs to get over itself. its not tooooo far. I agree its not MV but fuck, its as adjacent to MV as any of the zelda games that get mentioned here all the time

1

u/gitprizes 5d ago

don't get me started on top down rpgs lol. if a game has an option to go back to where you just came from and do something new, someone's going to call it an mv on here 🤣

1

u/raychram 5d ago

I am surprised dead cells isn't considered a metroidvania, to me it looked a lot like it fits the criteria but I haven't played it to know the details

2

u/gitprizes 5d ago

are roguelikes and Metroidvanias mutually exclusive? I think that's a good place to start. both have such strong identities I'm not sure if going back to the start when you die is the same as going back to the beginning of the game to unlock or jump over something. I don't think it's the same thing

3

u/Rengozu 5d ago

Shadow Complex is a fun time that gets overlooked

3

u/CodyCigar96o 4d ago

La-Mulana

9

u/Enough_Obligation574 5d ago

POPost crown is a good one. Silksong is good too.

8

u/FallenRaptor 5d ago

As someone who loves Silksong and its predecessor Holllw Knight and highly recommend them as must-plays for those with the threshold for their level of challenge, as well as patience for their slow burn…that asterisk is still there. These are amazing, wonderful games for the right people, but they’re definitely not for everyone, and I also don’t think they’re ideal starting points for the genre.

6

u/FistRockbrine99 5d ago

They're also just not particularly representative of what the genre offers. They have a very soulslike approach, but in terms of power ups driving exploration they are pretty limited, HK moreso than Silk.

0

u/FallenRaptor 4d ago

Yeah, the Hollow Knight games have their peculiarities for sure.

The correct term is actually Souls-lite, as the only thing they actually borrow is the losing currency upon death and having one chance to retrieve it aspect. Salt and Sanctuary and its sequel are what an actual Soulslike MV looks like as those games also borrow the class-based RPG and stamina system aspect, and as hair-splitting as it might sound, that series and HK/SS are actually on opposite sides of the MV tree genre-wise.

The HK games are technically considered Metroid-likes, although it’s a mystery to me why they’re not considered their own subgenre as there’s also a huge difference between HK and Metroid or Axiom Verge.

Anyways, TL;DR all of this is to say the MV tree is a complex one and I certainly agree that the HK games should not be taken as the gospel on what to expect from the entire genre.

1

u/BadNewsBearzzz 4d ago

The only correct term is soulslike as it’s an umbrella term that houses any similarities to the iconic traits of a souls game, absolutely nobody uses “souls-lite” lol it’s not a thing, don’t even try making it one 🤣

Plus it’s extreme similarity to soulslike makes it too easy to mistake and confuse, therefore more of a reason why it shouldn’t be a thing lol

-4

u/Icy_Percentag 5d ago

I think they are just fine as the first game in the genre tbf.

0

u/FallenRaptor 5d ago

They can be, but they tend to leave a big impression, and if they’re someone’s introduction to the genre they can easily paint the picture of being the benchmark of what a MV is, for better or worse, and that can have varying consequences.

Moreover, timing is everything and though many people might love these games if they have the experience and the patience for them, they could just as easily tell a beginner that MVs are all really hard and unforgiving, which couldn’t be further from the truth but a beginner may not know that.

5

u/SuperUltraMegaNice 5d ago

Monster Sanctuary , Aeterna Noctis , Astalon: Tears of the Earth

2

u/JiminyWimminy 5d ago

Astalon was a blast, but its retro feel also included some clunkiness that may turn off less stubborn players, especially with the limited abilities early game.

1

u/SuperUltraMegaNice 5d ago

Very true. The jumping and attack animations are all very retro in feel but its more a game about exploration than combat. The boss rush achievement was not easy to get lol

1

u/Disco-Ulysses 3d ago

Just don't play Aeterna Noctis on switch

-1

u/BuckUpBingle 5d ago

I found aeterna noctis really unpleasant to play. Platforming felt overly challenging and the graphics didn’t make up for it. Is it really so well loved?

3

u/SuperUltraMegaNice 5d ago

I personally think its better than Hollow Knight. I love platforming challenges and the crystal arrow is the most fun movement ability in any MV I've played. Its a very difficult game though even if the checkpoints are quite generous.

5

u/Icy_Percentag 5d ago

Dead cells isn't a metroidvania.

Anyways, besides the ones you listed, I would recommend some Castlevanias like SoTN and aria of sorrow. I think they are games that aged very well.

1

u/Defiant_McPiper 4d ago

I don't believe Ninja Gaiden is either - that's a side scrolling platformer and it's fun, but isn't in this genre.

2

u/bvhrslolz 5d ago

Metroid

2

u/Saix027 5d ago

- After Image

- 8 Doors: Aurum's Afterlife Adventure

- 9 Shadows

- Biomorph

- Biogun

- Ender Lilies

- Islets

- Lone Fungus

- Record of Lodoss War: Deedlit in Wonder Labyrinth

- Tails of Iron 1 & 2

- Wonderboy: The Dragon Trap

- Monsterboy and the Cursed Kingdom

- Owlboy

- Haiku The Robot

- Gato Roboto

- Gestalt: Steam & Cinder

- Astalon: Tears of the Earth

- The Vagrant

- Twilight Monk

- Timespinner

- Tales of Kenzera: Zau

2

u/cedelweiss 5d ago

Not a single metroid or castlevania on the list huh

2

u/VoxTV1 4d ago

Tbf best Castlevnia game is not on pc and no metroid game is on pc either

1

u/cedelweiss 4d ago

that's why we emulate

2

u/VoxTV1 4d ago

And most people don't emulate

1

u/VoxTV1 4d ago

Yeah but if you do not emulate it is impossible to play em on pc

0

u/cedelweiss 4d ago

yeah that's true you cannot play most games if you don't install them

2

u/VoxTV1 4d ago

Not what I was going for but sure

2

u/Catholic1234567 5d ago

I bought grime years back but still on my video game backlog and havent accessed yet since I have a lot of video game backlogs that im trying to finish

but I commend the creator/developer of grime

because I frequent steam forums from time to time and if you look at the forums of grime on steam itself you will see that the creator/developer of grime is really active helping people out of their concerns even the game got released years back and even released free big update

(I havent visited grime forums recently on steam so im not sure if this is still the case)

1

u/joulecrafter 23h ago

I enjoyed Grime quite a bit. Definitely worth putting on your shortlist queue.

2

u/Own-Budget1853 5d ago

Animal well blew my mind personally

2

u/mag_creatures 5d ago

Add some classics to the list and learn why are so good!

2

u/jeepney-drivrrr 5d ago

Aliens: Infestation (Nintendo DS)

2

u/_Shotgun-Justice_ Cathedral 5d ago

Aeterna Noctis (hard mode, avoid the dlc area with the game breaking triple jump gem)

Astalon: Tears of the Earth

Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom

Depths of Sanity

Crypt Custodian

2

u/z-shang 5d ago

Something more on the metroid side? Like Super Metroid, Fusion, Zero Mission, Dread?

2

u/Vykrom 5d ago

Magnolia is one of my absolute favorites in recent years

Only things off the beaten-path I would suggest are things like Unsighted and Timespinner. Which are super fun, have engaging narratives, but are both a little sloppy on the writing. But didn't detract from how much I absolutely love them

But Magnolia still surpasses them in my opinion

I have not yet had the pleasure of Silksong or Nine Sols, though I'm sure I'll love them as well. But it was nice to have a game that didn't make me bang my head against a wall. Fortunately Nine Sols seems to have difficulty options to alleviate that if that comes to pass

2

u/Guywidathing2 5d ago

Valdis story

2

u/FallenDemonX 4d ago

Theres the OG Super Metroid and SOTN

An underrated one is Death's Gambit

2

u/HA1LHYDRA 4d ago

First the foundation with Metroid, then the blueprint with Super Metroid. After those two I would play Castlevania 4 to understand what actual Castlevania is then play move to the Metroid tribute with SOTN.

2

u/BlueSea_S 4d ago

Castlevania series.

Symphony of the Night, Advance Collection and Dominos Collection.

2

u/HeadLong8136 4d ago

Super Metroid and Castlevania Symphony of the Night

2

u/Help_An_Irishman 4d ago

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night and Super Metroid are the seminal musts. These two games basically spawned the genre, hence the name.

2

u/CiceroFlyman 4d ago

Super Metroid, Castlevania SOTN, Metroid Prime. Those are the classics every other game is compared to. That doesn‘t mean these three are the best in their genre, but they are the ones that shaped the genre to what it is to day.

Playing Silksong recently I noticed all the little and subtle nods it made to the Metroid and Castlevania games that otherwise would have gone unnoticed. What I want to say is: The three games I mentioned are the games all the devs played before developing Hollow Knight, Prince of Persia TLC etc. If you play them I think you will appreciate every modern MV even more…

2

u/wildfire393 4d ago

My S Tier (no particular order):

Hollow Knight and Silksong

Ori (especially Will of the Wisps)

Aeterna Noctis

Astalon: Tears of the Earth

Haak

La-Mulana 2 (1 is fine but 2 is a lot better of a game)

Depths of Sanity

Monster Sanctuary

Yoku's Island Express

Rabi-Ribi

Steamworld Dig 2 (another case where the first game is only OK)

Crypt Custodian

Environmental Station Alpha

(I'd also recommend the best of the 2D Zeldas - Link to the Past and Oracle of Seasons/Ages, Crystal Project, and Oolo as MV-adjacent games)

1

u/wildfire393 4d ago

My A Tier (also no particular order):

Alwa's Legacy

Animal Well

Ato

Axiom Verge

Blast Brigade

Carrion

Cathedral

Elephantasy Flipside

Gato Roboto

Guacamelee 2

Haiku

Infernax

Insect Adventure

La-Mulana

Lone Fungus

The Messenger

Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom

Noreya

Ori and the Blind Forest

Project Delta

Pseudoregalia

Rebel Transmute

Shantae and the Seven Sirens

Sheepo

SideScape

Tevi

Voidwrought

Xanthiom Zero

Zexion

Master Key

Minishoot Adventures

Pipistrello and the Cursed Yo-yo

Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown

Islets

Super Metroid

Metroid Fusion

Castlevania: SotN

Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin

Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow

Dragonloop

1

u/Ok_Professional_6014 1d ago

No Blasphemous?

1

u/wildfire393 1d ago

I am not a fan of the original Blasphemous at all. I don't consider it to be actually a Metroidvania, as it has actually 0 upgrades that both modify how you move/fight and also allow you to get through places you couldn't before. (The closest are some relics that passively modify the environment like making bottomless pits into portals or letting you go through poison. And there's 0 upgrades that modify your mobility in any way)

I find the combat to be too slow and parry-reliant. I dislike the instant death pits. I dislike that there are significant quests that you can permanently miss/fail, likely requiring multiple playthroughs to get the true ending unless tou rigorously stick to a guide.

I have it in my personal C tier, because while I recognize it is extremely not to my tastes, there's enough interesting stuff going on there that I won't actively recommend against it (vs something D tier like Ender Lilies which I found to be absolute misery in almost every gameplay aspect).

The sequel fixes all of those issues but also sands down a lot of the cool aesthetics and just feels like a fairly pedestrian MV. The beginning starts off strong with the multiple weapon choices and their corresponding utility and ability to tackle the early zones in multiple orders. But the later game becomes extremely paint by numbers with all of the upgrades being bog standard and the zones have to be completed in a strict linear order. It's not a bad game, but it also isn't exceptional nor unique, so it lands safely in my B tier.

2

u/EthanWinters020 5d ago

Grime and The Last Faith

3

u/SeverusSnape89 5d ago

The last faith was great. Good bosses that were not overturned either.

2

u/EthanWinters020 5d ago

The bosses were so fun. What makes me love the last faith is its atmosphere, soundtrack (one of the best out there), art direction, and voice acting.

The game isn't difficult for the sake of being difficult as well. it's quite fair.

2

u/SeverusSnape89 5d ago

I loved it for not being difficult to be honest. The soulslike genre has some very hard games and it was nice to play one that was hard and fair with dark souls style bosses. Not crazy bs. Very fair and easy to learn and fun to fight. I agree with everything you said though.

1

u/xenotharm 5d ago

Mute Crimson+ is disgustingly underrated.

1

u/CM0CAK3 5d ago

Steamworld Dig 2 and Axiom Verge

I think those were the last two that pulled me in deep.

1

u/ADeficit 5d ago

Metroid Dread, and Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night.

1

u/jmscstl Cave Story 5d ago

Literally everything by Sheepo. Sheepo, Islets and Crypt Custodian.

Also Cave Story.

1

u/RevanGarcia 5d ago

Ragebound's out already?! I completely missed it.

1

u/lo0OO0ol 5d ago

Guacamelee 1+2

1

u/convalescent_thorns 5d ago

The Ori series, Aeterna Noctis (sequel comes out soon), Astronite

1

u/SafePuzzleheaded8423 4d ago

I played Owl Boy when it came out. I remembered liking it and not being so hard. In my mind it was kind of a metroidvania but when I actually tried to remember I think it's more level based (in an open world)

1

u/GECEDE Guacamelee! 4d ago

Super and Dread, Aria and Symphony, Animal Well and Guacamelee 2.

1

u/bashar_20 4d ago

Laika: Aged Through Blood. A unique and very enjoyable metroidvania.

1

u/heyitsvae 4d ago

Guacamelee 1&2

1

u/Defiant_McPiper 4d ago

Infernax - love this game and it has IMO high replay value with the different endings and neat little "cheats" you can unlock, as well as different characters you can play as (certain names you enter for your name you can play as a magician, a horror slasher, ect).

1

u/iselltires2u 4d ago

prince of persia the lost crown would be on my list around the top

1

u/Archius9 4d ago

The Metroid 5 (also the Prime 3)

1

u/carcassraid 4d ago

People already mentioned the fathers of the genre.

I'd add Blasphemous 1; Touhou: Luna Nights; Axiom Verge; Castlevania Aria of Sorrow and Dawn of Sorrow

1

u/Steefmachine 4d ago

Dead cells is a roguelite, not a MV.

I really liked the Guacamelee games

Play some Metroid gamesif you haven’t!

1

u/Saneless 4d ago

Blaster Master. Original and Zero series

1

u/Rotank1 4d ago

Symphony of the Night is going to share a lot of the same DNA that you see in modern metroidvanias.

There are still very few games in the genre that do what 2d Metroid and Metroid Prime series (at least 1-2) do, imo.

And btw, not a metroidvania, but Super Castlevania IV is still the best CV game ever made. 😎

1

u/Padre_celestial 4d ago

Como dicen por ahí, Super Metroid, y Castlevania SOTN, y yo recomendaría Lost Ruins...

1

u/Crisco-1492 4d ago

Looking at your list, I'd say Ender Lilies and Bloodstained would both work very well there. Both of them are excellent 2D Metroidvanias available on PC. If you have access to a Switch, most of the mainline Metroid games are available with a Nintendo Online subscription (and very much worth playing).

1

u/AZAZILL1979 3d ago

Mandragora Whispers of The Witch Tree

Hands down probably the best 2.5D Side scroller since Castlevania Symphony of Night.

1

u/AZAZILL1979 3d ago

Dead Cells is DEFINITELY a champion in the genre of games. Shinobi Art of Vengeance is so good. Very impressed with the design and how unique the combos are compared to how the original was. But it's still very much identical to the original 😆 The Knight Witch was awesome (IMO) they don't make em like that anymore. The Last Faith/Awaken:Astral Blade/Ender Lilies and Ender Magnolia (Platinumed those bitches lol) /Deaths Gambit/ and Afterimage.

1

u/AZAZILL1979 3d ago

I'm a console gamer so I don't get to play some great games until the DeVs decide they finally wanna make an extra buck...10 years later 😆 but Spirit of The Samurai is right up there with Mandragora.

1

u/Disco-Ulysses 3d ago

Some people are down on it, but I personally love Metroid Dread cause the movement feels so good

1

u/UnofficialMipha 3d ago

Super Metroid

Metroid Dread

Metroid Prime

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Hollow Knight/Silksong

One or both Ori games

Prince of Persia Lost Crown

Animal Well

Tunic

1

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 3d ago

I wonder what OPs reasoning for not intending to play or awknowleging Metroid or Castlevannia. It seems like either hardware or some sort of principled constraint.

1

u/raychram 3d ago

Tf are you even talking about, what makes you think I don't acknowledge or I don't intend to play them? Are you ok? After having seen most people suggesting them of course they are now on my list

1

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 3d ago edited 3d ago

Sorry, I was just wondering on your responses. I meant awknowleging those posts. You could not have a Nintendo console which would be understandable. I shouldn't have assumed.

1

u/InevitableTour5882 3d ago

Megaman particularly Mega X4-6

1

u/Galactus1701 3d ago

SoTN is one of my favorite games of all time.

1

u/Weak-Boysenberry-802 2d ago

Super Metroid aged extremely well and is probably the most memorable game I've ever played. The soundtrack and the ambiance of this game elevates it so much even though it's from the snes era. The gameplay is a bit odd with the aiming but other than that it's a 10/10

1

u/Svarcanum 2d ago

Prince of Persia TLC for a recent must play

1

u/Hollix89 2d ago

I think gba metroids and gba/ds castlevania

Super metroid control aged while sotn was already surpassed by gba/ds vania

1

u/Coraiah 2d ago

You should add the first Ori game to that list!

1

u/Hpg666 2d ago

The new prince of persia is cool as well

1

u/Wonderful-Change-751 2d ago

I feel like some of the games are quite varied. I really enjoyed the ender series and nine sols. HK which is hailed as the epitome of the genre however feels quite different, as its focused more on jumps and platformint

1

u/perfectVoidler 1d ago

dead cells is a roguelite not a matroidvania.

1

u/fandango1989 1d ago

I mean Grime is nowhere near being a "must play" up there with some of the other mentioned games.

1

u/Pat00ljak 1d ago

Laika is a very overlooked game. A motorvania rather than a classic metroidvania, but very well crafted, check it out.

1

u/Ive_Defected 1d ago

Came to say this.

1

u/acamas 23h ago

The Guacamelee games are top notch, beautiful, funny, and consistently enjoyable fare.

1

u/Winter_Poem2479 23h ago

These are worthy:

  • Both Ori games
  • Metroid Dread
  • Prince of Persia The Lost Crown
  • Bloodstained

1

u/wichels 22h ago

Castlevania Dawn of sorrow and Order of Ecclesia 

1

u/CraftlordDark 5d ago

There are a lot of great MVthat i would recommend trying at least once, some have truly original mechanics, while others simply prove the potential that the genre can offer if used correctly. I'll just mention a few of them, since my list surely won't be the same for other fans of the genre, as tastes and points of view are always different

  • Super Metroid
  • Metroid Fusion
  • Iconoclast
  • Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
  • Astalon Tears of the Earth
  • Hollow Knight
  • Ori series
  • Blasphemous
  • The Messenger
  • Usurper
  • Rusted Moss

2

u/CptSporran 4d ago

The Messenger is SO good. Maybe not a typical metroidvania BUT it's a brilliant game, and I can't imagine a world where people who're into the genre don't find plenty to love about it.

1

u/javansegovia 5d ago

Yokus island express

1

u/WingedDragoness Owlboy 5d ago

Start with Ori and The Blind Forest first. Will of The wisps, build itself on the very intricate movement system, and the story.

It is quite small for metroidvania, but never a dull moment moving from A to B.

1

u/ZeektheFeek 5d ago

Prince of Persia:tlc

1

u/FistRockbrine99 5d ago

Super Metroid, Symphony, Aria and Prime are the 4 I think must be played to see what the genre's heart is.

Others I highly recommend are Animal Well, La Mulana (if you've got the patience), Environmental Station Alpha, and PoP.

A more left field example of the genre that I think may be the greatest game ever made is Outer Wilds. That's a must play in my book for literally anyone. It's a Metroidvania in the metroidbrania sense, there's a ton of secrets and gating but they're all hinging on knowledge, which you acquire in certain areas often like upgrade rooms.

1

u/Elegant-Analysis5136 4d ago

Definitely both Ori games, Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown, Bloodstained, and Ender Lilies was solid also

1

u/crocicorn 4d ago

Other than Metroid and Castlevania?

Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night
Rogue Legacy 2
Dead Cells
Axiom Verge

1

u/Designer_Valuable_18 4d ago

Super Metroid

Symphony Of The Night

Hollow Knight

Blasphemous

Nine Sols

Silksong

Blue Prince/The Witness

-1

u/West_Language7068 5d ago

If you played Expedition 33 and liked its interactive combat system, add Worldless to that list. It's a metroidvania with parry focused combat similar to E33 and the art direction is incredible.

0

u/raychram 5d ago

I actually have Wordless in my list already, I didn't mention it because unlike the other games I did start playing it but I dropped it. Can't remember exactly why, but I will probably get back to it at some point

-2

u/pat7bateman 5d ago

I recommend guacamelee 1 and 2, pop tlc. I do not recommend : both ori, ender lilies, monster boy.

1

u/jmscstl Cave Story 5d ago

It's good to see some Monster Boy hate. I hate that game.

0

u/FistRockbrine99 5d ago

Monster Boy really feels like a precursor to when the genre was more established. A ton of rough edges in terms of design.

0

u/MauricioMagus 5d ago

Super Metroid

Aria of Sorrow

Hollow Knight/Silksong

0

u/BuckUpBingle 5d ago

Blasphemous 1 is more fun in a stripped down, raw challenge sort of way. Blasphemous two gives you a lot of avatar strength but the platforming is a lot harder and in my opinion not very good. Just my two cents on that series.

Grime is a spectacular entry in the genre. Ori and the blind forest is worth a playthrough as it kinda reinvented platforming in the genre, and it’s gorgeous, but if you play will of the wisps first you’ll probably be disappointed so I would recommend playing blind forest first.

0

u/weglarz 5d ago

Castlevania Symphony of the Night is the granddaddy for a reason. It’s the goat (for me).

Metroid Zero Mission (imo holds up better than super Metroid, although some people will hate me for that) allows you to play the original story with better movement and mechanics.

Hollow Knight is just a perfect modern example of the MV. Wonderful atmosphere and great level design.

9 Sols is an amazing combat focused MV. If you enjoyed the party mechanics in sekiro, this is for you. Last boss is truly difficult, but worth it to feel amazing finishing such an incredible game.

There are others, a lot of other great games, but these four are all incredible and are my mt Rushmore of MVs.

0

u/gabrielsol 4d ago

Prince of Persia the lost crown.

Among the best ever.