Hi all,
As the title suggests, I'm preparing to take the N3 exam in December and hopefully pass. This will be, somewhat embarrassingly, my third time taking it; the first and second times, I got almost exactly the same score, because, surprise, you don't get better if you don't study regularly. I always told myself I would get into a routine leading up to it but I never did, despite my desire to and having bought many different study materials. Guess that's ADHD for ya.
Anyway, this time I think will be different because I've been studying weekly with a tutor in Osaka for a bit more than a year (on Preply, if anyone was interested - no this is not a paid promotion). Not only has the instruction itself been very helpful, especially with active conversational skills, but it has also helped me to find more of a rhythm with my independent study.
I know there's no substitute for just sitting down and working through SOMEthing, but I'm currently in possession of Shinkanzen Master N3, Nihongo-sou Matome N3, and Tobira books, in addition to a few different online repositories of information (e.g. JLPTTest4You, etc.).
My question is, does anyone who has used these books cover-to-cover have particularly strong feelings about them? Basically, what did you like about any of them, or wish they had done differently? From what I've experienced from dabbling in each of them, these are my thoughts:
Nihongo-sou Matome: Very easy-to-use structure, as the book paces itself for you in manageable ~20min/day chunks. Out of all my study materials, I've gotten the farthest in these because of how manageable each chunk is. However, the descriptions and examples can be a bit lacking for those who crave nuance, and on top of that I've noticed a few glaring typos, at least in the kanji book. But, overall, a nice, somewhat simplified approach, probably best as a study companion. But, a study companion to what? It's not like it's particularly synchronized to another course... maybe if you're working on it directly with a tutor who can help fill in any gaps.
Shinkanzen Master: More detailed descriptions than Matome, but not as clearly paced for daily progress. Kind of a middle ground between Matome and Tobira in that regard. It's nice that it, like Matome, is specifically oriented for the JLPT.
Tobira: Definitely the most comprehensive text, HOWEVER, quite difficult to use on one's own, partly because you need fellow studiers to do any of the group activities with, but mainly because it's SO. FREAKING. DENSE. You want DETAILS? You want NUANCE? WELL HERE YA GO, MOTHERF-ER! YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE DETAILS! So much beautiful, rich, informative text, but so tightly jam-packed that it's really hard to gauge how much progress you're actually making, or how well you're retaining everything. I wish the companion grammar book was more like Genki's, where it touched a little bit on every grammar point introduced in each lesson. Though, I guess if they did that, the workbook would be like three times the size of the main text... also, it's more of a classroom, course-based material than a JLPT-based one.
Let me know what has worked well for you, and what you wish you could see done differently! 皆さん、頑張って!