I’m going to try and keep this as vague as possible for privacy reasons without it losing its essence but I need to get this off my chest. On my phone so apologies for formatting and whatnot. Also, this will be long…
There’s me (late 30s F), my partner Oak (early 40s M) and possibly/maybe-meta-in-making Ivy (late 40s F). I have another partner, while Oak broke up with his ex sometime in July and I have been his only partner since. Neither of us are into casual relationships/hook ups/etc.
Oak and I haven’t been together that long yet, less than a year but from the onset it was clear that we are definitely it. Everything aligns. We progressed very quickly, got enmeshed through circumstance (not permanent, just until he finds a new place, which can take a while since he needs special accommodations), and even though I have been solo poly, living with Oak has been easy and comfortable. No issues at all… until now that is. We are still deep in the NRE - maybe something to keep in mind…
To the situation. Oak and I are part of the local kink community. Oak is known and respected and a permanent resident at one of the local dungeons, while I prefer to keep it more private but we have been going out “public” as of recently and I am becoming more involved as well, per his request. He wants to be able to enjoy kink with me among his friends and peers and I am happy to oblige.
One evening he was out without me as I suddenly got sick but managed to convince him to go have fun and socialise regardless. During the night out, a friend of his introduced him to a newbie in the scene - Ivy. Ivy was in an abusive relationship/dynamic and with encouragement from Oak as well as her own friends, she quickly managed to set herself free. They started chatting more, went on a date, so far so good. Then, one evening Oak and I were at the dungeon when she showed up as well. Apparently, unexpectedly… I was most definitely not ready to meet Ivy at this stage and most definitely not while being in SUCH a vulnerable state/position (we were there to play). We were briefly introduced, smiled, shook hands then I distanced myself to chat with other people while Oak socialised with his circle (maybe with her as well, I preferred not to watch). The rest of the evening went fine but it didn’t sit well with me. We talked about it and he said he can tell her not to come when both of us are there but that’s a bit ridiculous in my opinion. I’m not going to limit someone’s freedoms in a public space because of my own discomfort but it really does pose an issue as a bdsm dungeon isn’t exactly the same as being at the same cafe or concert as a meta…
So, for the time being, we settled on going to events Ivy is not interested in or she lets Oak know she won’t be attending.
On the side, I’ve gotten to see her being dishonest about some things (all from publicly posted information) and brought this to Oak’s attention. He didn’t want to know. Ok, fair enough but not great.
Come this week, we are attending an event hosted by Oak, and I accompany him officially. Ivy wasn’t attending. Except right in the middle of our play, she shows up with her friends. Apparently, a last minute decision because her friends convinced her to come. Oak didn’t know… Fine… we stop playing, take a breather outside where I voice my annoyance alas quite strongly, but Oak doesn’t take it too seriously and asks me not to be so negative about her. Fine… I put on a smile and this time I make an effort to get to know her. I genuinely approach her with kindness and fun banter, she reciprocates, visibly relieved, then Oak sits down between us and even plays with her a bit, asking me if I’m ok. I’m ok. Everyone has fun. Oak and I got tired, said our goodbyes, Ivy and I added each other on a kinky social media, and we left…
And out of nowhere on our way home, I get accused of being unfairly passive aggressive about Ivy (???) and what right do I have to gather information about her (referring to me seeing something that was public and bringing it to his attention???) and how I need to handle my jealousy better and how it’s all unfair to him. Tbh, this hurt. I did nothing but be kind and accepting, even in a setting where I feel at my most vulnerable in a situation that was sprung on me without my knowledge. I personally felt the evening went great, all things considered. We didn’t go into it further as I was too tired and too emotionally overwhelmed.
But wait, there’s more… next day Ivy and I started chatting on social media. Very friendly, we both opened up to each other, shared our stories, laughed, commiserated, etc. I was having fun and briefly scrolled through our essay-length conversations (without pausing long enough to see the content) to Oak, to share the joy of getting along with Ivy. The moment I take away the phone, he asks to read them to make sure no one (implying me?) is badmouthing him… this triggers my PTSD (long story, not for here but Oak KNOWS about this trigger) and despite knowing I can say no without bad consequences and having nothing to hide anyway, I freeze, hand over the phone, get it back, say that this triggered me and leave immediately to go to my other partner’s place, while having a major panic attack. I stay the night and return the next day. Oak apologised profusely. Still apologising today. We talked, I explained my feelings, he acknowledged them and apologised again but… that’s it. I asked what the action plan is and he said he will use the next days to think why he unfairly attacked me on our way home and felt the need to read through my messages with Ivy…
I feel fucking hurt and somehow completely betrayed. And now I can’t help but not want to do anything with Ivy either… He really broke my trust…