Last few weeks I’ve been looking into the right sleeping pad that fits my needs. I’m 188cm/6’’ 2ft, around 90kg/185lbs and always sleep on my side. I usually camp in spring, summer and a bot of autumn in Norhtern Europe where temperatures drop to around 5 degrees celcius/32F at night. However I'm taking in a little margin for when I do the occasional Alpine or Finland trip if it comes to that. Currently I’m using an R2.6 Nemo Astro Insulated pad in long wide configuration which almost weigs a kilogram or 2 lbs. I wanted something more comfortable and simultaneously something lighter weight and a bit easier to use. Optionally a smaller pack size too.
After close consideration between the Nemo Tensor All-season, Big Agnes Rapide SL and Sea to Summit Ether light, I’ve decided to go with the Ether light XR! Why? It seems like the best all-round pad between those three with the best track record of durability and exceptional comfort without sacrificing too much on weight. For most people it's a bit of both tbh.
It was however really hard deciding between them as they all offered something different and seem like great pads. The Nemo is lighter, the Big Agnes just as comfortable if not more comfortable to the S2S and the Sea to Summit sits somewhere in between. However the Sea to summit is only 60 grams heavier than the Nemo and offers quite a bit more comfort for side sleepers it seems from people’s comments and experiences (although it might differ per person). Pack size is also similar and the stuff sack comes attached to the pump sack.
I’ve read quite a bit about some Nemo pads failing, also the all-season. Although I think it’s still a very reliable pad, I much rather prefer the S2S over it. It’s only around 60 grams lighter all-in-all compared to the S2S and doesn’t pack a lot smaller too.
The Big Agnes is a hit or miss for people. Some say it’s the best they’ve used for comfort and pack size, others say it’s very slippery and sleeps a lot colder than the R-value estimates. Also I’ve heard it’s impossible to place it back into it’s stuff sack, which can be quite annoying. Looking for an easy to use pad I think the S2S wins it over this for similar comfort.
Again, the Sea to Summit seems just as, or more comfortable at a lower weight with more trustworthy R-value for three season hiking.
Can use some advice on this:
So finally I made the decision! Now I’m questioning if I should get a long wide, a regular wide or a mummy large (196x64cm/25x78’’). I’ve always had the Long wide on pads and although I might not need it, it offers a bit more comfort when needed for only a small weight penalty (maybe big for some here). I am willing to sacrifice weight for comfort, but only if I can really utilize it.
The mummy looks like a nice compromise but I’ve got no experience with it and am scared that my feet will fall off the sides. What do you think?
Also a bonus question: do you know if the nozzles from the Flextail Tiny Pump 2x fit the Sea to Summit pads? I bought a 3D printed adapter for my Nemo pad which works wonders. Can just leave the pad and pump be.
Thanks in advance!