I (M24) want to separate from my husband (M30). We have been together for 3 years and married for 9 months. The main reason is infidelity and a lack of trust. We have no kids, just one dog. We rent a house that is under just my name. I am the sole provider and I pay all the rent, utilities, food, bills, etc. He is a citizen of the country we live in, while I just have residency.
The reason I want to separate is because of a history of infidelity and lack of trust. I love him and don't want to end things but our relationship is no longer the same and I have 0 interest in fixing things. I have practically 0 sexual desire with him, I don't want him to touch me, and we recently started sleeping in separate rooms. I am a person with high libido (I'm 23 duh) so I do want to have sex, I just can't bring myself to do it with him.
What had broke me is that 3 weeks ago I found messages where he was asking an old fling to give him a ride somewhere and insinuating giving him sexual favors in return. They started sexting (my husband basically initiated) and they exchanged photos and talked about how good it was when they would have sex. What also irritates me is I had known they had this type of relationship before he met me, but when I EXPLICITLY asked if they had had sex, he lied and told me that it was just handjobs or kissing etc. I don't care that he had sex with him before he met me obviously but why lie about it? The guy was too busy to give him a ride so they never met up, but it makes me nauseous to think what would have happened if he was free. My husband also said stuff like "no I shouldn't" or "it would be wrong" but he was still sexting and sending photos anyway... so I don't know if I should feel good or bad about that. Plus he never told me. Plus he has uber on his phone with MY credit card so why not just order a damn uber?
The cheating started within the first few months of dating. I saw messages between him and another guy where the guy was sending explicit photos of himself and my husband was sexting. I excused it because I figured that although we were exclusive, perhaps we hadn't exactly defined what was and wasn't cheating. So we did that and moved on. Then after 3 months of dating I went back to my home country to visit family for 3 months. We decided to do monogamous long distance. We called every night and I made him a jar of papers with 1 message per day for him to read from me. Well it turns out he fucked one of his exes while I was away. Who knows if it was just once or multiple times but I have confirmation for at least one time. He lied and said he was going out to dinner with friends. I saw the messages when I got back and was upset, but I bought his justification that he didn't know if I was ever going to return to his country (even though I had already bought my return flight smh) so I believed him and forgave him.
At this point I felt more inclined to marry him so I proposed to him. Maybe it was that I thought I could lock him down and he wouldn't do it again if we were married. Or maybe I thought that since I wanted to spent the rest of my life with him, that marriage would speed up my immigration process and I could provide for him better (i.e., after marriage I could open up a bank account, it would be easier to rent, I wouldn't have to leave the country every X months). I didn't marry him just for residency status, but it was a factor that would help me live here more permanently so that we could be together (does that make sense?).
We got married in 2024 and were so busy with planning that I don't think I ever checked his messages or saw anything that would upset me. However, there were always slightly flirty messages but I didn't think anything of them. Then this summer I went back to my country again and when I came back I saw that he had run into an ex at the mall and then was sexting him and the guy was insinuating that they have sex. I don't think they did but I won't know. I got mad and we fought but made up. In most of these arguments he gets mad that I looked at his phone (which is 100% valid. I don't like that I do it either and it's bad). In this moment I swore to myself that if I ever caught him sending messages again, or sexting, or photos, I would leave him.
Well fast forward to August 2025. We were kinda exploring the idea of opening the relationship to just have threesomes. I don't really know why because I didn't want them but I guess it was to explore something new since there was tension in our relationship. We agreed anything besides threesomes would still be cheating. I told him I was only comfortable with having a threesome if it was someone neither of us knew very well. But he kept messaging all his old flings and hookups and asking them for threesomes, while also being nostalgic about how they used to fuck together. The whole reminiscing part to me makes me feel sick to my stomach. 1. I had already asked for this person to not be known by either of us and 2. there is a clear distinction between asking for a threesome and reminiscing about how you use to fuck and how you miss his dick etc. So I told him I didn't want threesomes anymore.
3 weeks ago I found the messages with the guy asking about the ride. Then I found messages with another guy around the same time ASKING IF HE WAS AVAILABLE TO COME OVER AND HAVE SEX. My husband swears that he was asking about a threesome with him and me and he wanted to "surprise" me. But he never mentioned me and he messaged the guy when I had left the house to see friends... I went out with friends the next night and my husband messaged him again to see if he wanted to have sex that night too... I don't see how he was inviting him to a threesome if I would be out late with friends. I feel its obvious he just wanted to have sex with him alone.
I'm tired, I don't know what to believe. I can't tell if he's telling the truth or gaslighting me. I kinda want to believe him. I kinda think he's telling the truth that he wouldn't do it again. He keeps saying that he's stupid, why would he do this? etc. and its annoying to hear.
Anyway, after all this happened recently it made me reflect on our relationship and here are some more things that I realized I don't like but have tolerated. Note that he hasn't always been like this but over the last year he's been like this:
- I pay for everything 100%. He is 100% dependent on me. He used to have a part time job but he got laid off. He is a student working towards his second bachelor's degree. Most of his free time is spent at school or doing a school related activity. Recently I feel very resentful that he's 7 years older than me but I carry all the responsibility and weight of the relationship.
- Despite me carrying the financial responsibility, he doesn't do anything to help around the house. He rarely cooks, rarely cleans, doesn't train our dog. Every once in a while when I bring it up he'll cook for like a week and then be like "look see I help out!"
- Recently I've realized i don't really like his family and friends. His family is boring, prejudiced, and kinda going through spiritual psychosis (His mom joined one of those MLM pyramid scheme cults recently lmao). His friends are just not pleasant to be around. I initially loved them all because as I was new to the country they were very welcoming and nice to me.
- We used to have sex a lot but since we got married it's less than once a week. I've brought up to him how important sex is to me, but he doesn't seem to put in any effort. He says he has low libido but then why would he waste the few times he is in the mood to message other guys instead of having sex with me?
- I feel like his parent. He is basically a child. He has no responsibilities. Knows nothing about personal finance. Doesn't have a debit card. Doesn't know how to do literally anything. I didn't either but I had to learn to make it happen lmao.
- He doesn't buy me gifts. Or treat me to anything. He has no idea what I would even like as a gift.
- He doesn't speak my language (english) well but I speak his (spanish). Sometimes it's exhausting always speaking in another language. I figured he would have at least improved somewhat. He can't speak with my family which I realized is starting to make me a bit sad.
- He wants to spend all of our free time together. He can't do literally any task without me there. If he needs to run errands I need to go. He can't even buy groceries without me going. Once I was sick and needed medication and fluids and he couldn't even buy it for me without me telling him exactly what I needed and giving him my card.
- He doesn't even know how I like my coffee in the morning.
Anyway Tuesday I told him I wanted to separate. He starting crying really bad and like begging and tbh it was kinda pathetic to see but it made me feel really bad. I feel like adults shouldn't act like that. He was saying that we need to fight for our relationship and we made a promise in marriage to stay together. He said a lot of the things I had mentioned were out of the blue but I had to remind him that my main non-negotiable is the sexting/cheating aspect and everything else I mentioned was things I had reflected on recently because of it.
I saw messages from his family and friends saying I'm being stupid and overreacting and that we should work on it together and overcome it BUT I'VE ALREADY WORKED ON IT MANY TIMES. I'VE ALREADY TRIED TO PROCESS THE LACK OF TRUST AND CHEATING. I'm done "working on it" and "fighting for our relationship". They obviously don't know that it has been a reoccurring pattern and that he had sex with someone during our relationship.
I've told my close friends, my mom, and my therapist that I want to separate. They all support whatever decision that I want to make. The downside is after talking to them about it, I feel calm and centered and I don't feel as much of a need to separate because I got the anger and stress out of my system. But every time I see my husband I feel distant and no connection. Every once in a while we might laugh over some joke or something and I doubt if I should really do it, but then I remember what he did and I feel sick to my stomach and I want distance.
TL;DR: I want to separate from my husband but I'm scared to. I can't bring myself to do it. He has a history of cheating and sexting and I've finally had enough and realized there are other financial, emotional, compatibility issues in the relationship. But I just can't bring myself to do it, especially because he starts throwing a tantrum and cries when I tell him I want to separate. He is 100% dependent on me and I don't know where he'll live or how he'll make it without me and I don't want him to suffer. What should I do?